Elgar: The Kingdom review – respectful and admirable, but this is still a work hard to love

Chiejina/Connolly/Hulett/Riches/Crouch End Fest Chorus/London Mozart Players/Temple(Signum, two CDs)An excellent choir and impressive soloists do justice to Elgar’s rather inert oratorio but don’t quite match existing recordings Completed in 1906, The Kingdom was intended as the central panel in what Elgar had conceived as a New Testament triptych, preceded by The Apostles, from three years earlier and to have been followed by The Last Judgement, a score that got no further than a few sketches. Elgar himself thought highly of The Kingdom, calling it “the best of me”, and though it has never achieved the popularity of The Dream of Gerontius, some Elgarians have agreed with him, claiming it as the greatest of his oratorios, with its orchestral writing in particular seen as far superior. Yet where Gerontius has operatic roots, which give it a compelling dramatic intensity, The Kingdom seems to be wedded too much to the Victorian oratorio, which for all its incidental highpoints makes it inert and uninvolving.That lack of popularity is reflected in the scarcity of recordings. This performance, conducted by David Temple and recorded in the newly restored Victorian theatre at Alexandra Palace in London, seems to be only the fourth of the complete work currently available. Temple is clearly a huge admirer of the score – “a gem from first note to last”, he calls it – and that admiration shines through his performance with the excellent Crouch End Festival Chorus and a fine quartet of soloists. But to my ears at least it lacks immediacy and, alongside the existing versions – conducted by Adrian Boult, Richard Hickox and Mark Elder, it never quite matches up, for all its good intentions. Continue reading...

Comments

Culture

Every Kneecap show cancelled so far amid police investigation

Comments

Culture

Every Kneecap show cancelled so far amid police investigation

All of the Kneecap gigs that have been cancelled amid police probe

The Traitors star Minah Shannon joins BBC Radio 1

Alec Baldwin’s Rust deemed ‘uninspired’ and ‘a tough slog’ by critics years after fatal on-set tragedy

Morgan Wallen’s label sells $200 million stake in his catalog

The First Minister does not get to decide who plays TRNSMT festival

Honour for former Herald critic after half a century as arts champion

Clooney gets Tony nomination for Broadway debut

George Clooney says the press has a duty to 'always question authority'

‘The Four Seasons’ Review: Tepid Trouble in Middle-Aged Paradise

In New York, Art Abounds This May Amid Market Uncertainty

Review: Trisha Brown’s Unstable, Liquid Structures

Tony Nominations Snubs and Surprises: Denzel Washington Misses for ‘Othello’ and More

Inside Holly Willoughby’s family life with husband Dan and kids after kidnap plot horror

'I am sorry': Searing antisemitism report spurs apology, reforms from Harvard president

Apple sends two spyware notifications to victims in Europe

Blake Lively delights in Another Simple Favour, but this is otherwise too silly a sequel

Ed Sheeran announces release date for eighth album ‘Play’

Jade Thirlwall left speechless by blunt X-Factor question on The Assembly

'Subtle it ain't...': The Merry Widow at the Theatre Royal in Glasgow

Cynthia Erivo reveals she has been influenced by Blur and Oasis on new album

Faye Tozer to play historical Wild West figure in Dita Von Teese show

Ed Sheeran leaves maths series behind as he announces release date for Play

At Jazz at Lincoln Center, Dave Chappelle Rallies to Keep ‘Tradition Alive’

Stan Love, Athlete With a Beach Boys Connection, Dies at 76

Why do people think Stacey Solomon and Joe Swash ‘broke BBC rules’ on TV show?

Rita Ora left perplexed after Oscar-winning husband unveiled as surprise Masked Singer contestant

Lewis Pullman reveals dad Bill Pullman’s candid take on Thunderbolts* script

Rita Ora astonished as Masked Singer’s Lucky Duck revealed as familiar face

Strongest-ever line up is booked for The Gathering Festival in Inverness

BBC announces documentary and shows for Live Aid 40th anniversary

Bob Geldof says he's 'blue in the face' hearing Freddie Mercury's Live Aid performance with Queen

Soho Theatre Walthamstow opens: 'you will be taken aback by the aesthetic gorgeousness!'

2025 Tony nominations are out — and they're full of celebrities

Frieze, Premiere Art Fair Company, Sold on Eve of New York’s Art Week

George Clooney, Sarah Snook and Sadie Sink Get Tony Nominations

Former WWE champion, 46, ‘knows retirement is coming’ in near future

Netflix series scores 10,000,000 views in 4 days despite ‘worst ending ever’

Creepiest horror trailer in years leaves fans ‘struggling to sleep’

Transgender women soccer players to be banned from English women's teams

Tony Awards 2025 nominations: George Clooney gets nod while Denzel Washington snubbed

Moulin Rouge! The Musical, The Playhouse, Edinburgh: as thrilling as it is exhausting

The Four Seasons: Tina Fey's take on Alan Alda classic comedy is a sunny delight

Artwork by 19th century Scottish artist go on display in hometown exhibition

Minister: No-one in the House of Commons wants Kneecap to play Glastonbury

Overcompensating: what we know about Amazon's college show with Charli XCX and Megan Fox

BBC announces documentary and shows for Live Aid 40th anniversary

Sir David Attenborough hailed a ‘gift to humanity’ days before 99th birthday

Agatha Christie to be resurrected by AI to teach writing course nearly 50 years after her death

Sinners actor reveals secret name used to disguise Ryan Coogler film before release

Gruffalo to return in new book after 20 years

Poll: Should Kneecap be banned from playing at TRNSMT?

Paul Mescal headlines National Theatre’s bold new season as Stormzy debuts for ground-breaking collaboration

Robbie Williams: 'I’ve never asked the world to take me seriously'

Bob Geldof says another Live Aid event is ‘unlikely’ because of social media

Lorde announces new album Virgin and confirms release date

Daughter of murdered MP praises 'swift action' of counter-terror police's Kneecap investigation

Tony Awards Nominations 2025: Updating List

Race Across The World fans convinced they know who’s eliminated in major spoiler

Shogun season two officially confirmed as cast and production dates announced