Holding Liat review – powerful study of a family torn apart by Hamas’ 7 October attacks

Brandon Kramer’s documentary complicates any simple view of the Israel-Gaza war in its portrait of one family’s agonising divisionsAt the present moment, for pro-Palestinian campaigners, mention of the hostages and victims of Hamas’s 7 October attacks tends to be greeted with indifference, or even contempt. And yet this powerful and complex documentary, directed by Brandon Kramer (a distant relative of some of the people involved) and co-produced by Darren Aronofsky, is a reminder that the situation now can’t be understood without remembering the Hamas massacre – how it was calculated to provoke a rage-filled reaction that would discredit Israel internationally, what it meant and continues to mean within Israel and how the political and ideological connotations of the hostages have themselves evolved.At first, the hostages’ images were widely seen as a focus for outrage and a casus belli. Posters put up in cities showing the hostages were ripped down - to the fury of their families. But now the hostages’ images are associated more with anti-Netanyahu, anti-war-at-all-costs sentiment, with the families demanding real negotiating progress in getting them home. Continue reading...

Comments

Culture

Thursday Murder Club slips down Netflix chart after author reacts to huge plot change

Metro

Comments

Similar News

‘I never hold back’: Sally Mann on her controversial family photos and becoming a writer

Jess Glynne’s Hold My Hand named TikTok song of the summer after Jet2 trend

Austin Butler’s charisma holds Caught Stealing together

As Trump Tightens Hold on Kennedy Center, Top Theater Producer Resigns

Destination X’s casting decisions are holding it back from success

Channel 4 thriller In Flight is so tense I had to hold my breath

Flow Festival 2025, review – Charli xcx, Burna Boy and FKA Twigs headline but Finland’s own hold their ground

Culture

Thursday Murder Club slips down Netflix chart after author reacts to huge plot change

James McAvoy assaulted in Toronto bar after promoting directorial debut

Thomas Skinner issues apology after walking out of Strictly Come Dancing press event

Jimmy Kimmel blasts Republican ‘sycophants’ defending Trump over Epstein birthday book

John Cleese calls BBC comedy executives ‘clowns’ after frustrating meeting

Glen Powell credits Chris Pratt’s Marvel role for changing Hollywood

From wood engravings to Colin Firth: new exhibition depicts the stories of Jane Austen

David Bowie at the V&A East Storehouse review: This archive is utter stardust for Ziggy fans

Deaf Republic at Royal Court Jerwood Theatre : 'hugely powerful portrait of occupation'

Sophie Ellis-Bextor at KOKO: her star has re-risen for a whole new generation

Pulp, CMAT and Sam Fender among artists nominated for 2025 Mercury Prize

Tyler Perry accuser speaks out for first time since sexual assault lawsuit

Matt Damon says Beatles documentary convinced him to keep working with Ben Affleck

The flaw with Charlie Sheen’s memoir is the tragedy of his own life

Shirley Ballas teases Strictly ‘changes’ after Thomas Skinner walks out of event

Rock acts Fontaines DC, Sam Fender and Wolf Alice shortlisted for the 2025 Mercury Prize

Son of Bollywood superstar makes his debut with Netflix series all about nepo babies

The Bachelorette casting twist: Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star to lead season 22

‘Masterful’ Leonardo DiCaprio thriller tipped for Oscar glory after rave reviews

Great British Bake Off 2025 viewers relieved as fan favourite saved during tense biscuit week

Thomas Skinner walks out of Strictly Come Dancing press event

Britney Spears appears to defend Justin Bieber while addressing her own critics

Gregg Wallace launches legal action against BBC over MasterChef dismissal

‘House of the Dragon’ star Olivia Cooke on why intimacy coordinators are so important

17 great movies ruined by terrible endings

aka Charlie Sheen review – A selective tale of manic but benign destruction

Jon Stewart compares Trump to ‘Make-A-Wish kid’ following poor health rumours

‘The Conjuring’ house in Rhode Island to be auctioned off on Halloween

Anna Wintour admits Meryl Streep’s portrayal of her in The Devil Wears Prada was a ‘fair shot’

Glen Powell says ex is entitled to her ‘narrative’ after she slammed him for leaning into Sydney Sweeney romance rumors

Diana Vickers reveals why Dermot O’Leary got the ick during Glastonbury meeting

Samara Weaving: ‘Starring in a horror film shook the anxiety out of me – I didn’t need my meds after that’

Coldplay kiss cam scandal takes unexpected turn as husband of HR exec breaks silence

‘Exceptional’ thriller with unexpected twists shoots up Netflix top 10

‘I wrote two iconic gay anthems – the future of LGBT rights saddens me’

‘Alien: Earth’ Episode 6 Recap: Inhuman Sacrifices

See stunning shots of Chappell Roan, Charli XCX and Doja Cat up for music photo award

Charlie Sheen admits he hasn’t spoken to Jon Cryer amid ‘Two and a Half Men’ reboot rumors

What will happen to dance, with a major grant program changing?

Hollywood stars boycott Israeli film companies in response to Gaza crisis

Author Elizabeth Gilbert talks about trying to understand that she isn't a bad person

Ronda Rousey spurns Trump’s White House UFC event

Ryan Seacrest confirmed to return to American Idol after hosting gig was in limbo

Rosie O’Donnell says she missed daughter’s graduation over Trump feud

TV viewers declare ‘week is ruined’ after legendary BBC show’s comeback axed

A look at the summer and fall box office

The View takes an odd turn as panelists praise usual targets Boebert and MTG for demanding Epstein transparency

Leonardo DiCaprio reveals plans to ‘slow down’ after dominating Hollywood for decades

Gregg Wallace officially suing the BBC after Masterchef axing

Gregg Wallace launches legal action against BBC

Stephen Shore’s Precocious Adolescent Eye

Does Society Have Too Many Rules?

Orson Welles’ daughter ‘disgusted’ by Amazon-backed AI company’s plan to reconstruct lost film

Decomposing body found in Tesla reportedly registered to singer after passers-by notice foul smell coming from vehicle

Glen Powell says ex is entitled to her ‘narrative’ after she slammed him for leaning into Sydney Sweeney romance rumors

Anna Wintour admits Meryl Streep’s portrayal of her in The Devil Wears Prada was a ‘fair shot’

Everything we learned from Charlie Sheen’s brutally honest memoir

Strictly's Thomas Skinner leaves press event early

Spinal Tap is back. Director Rob Reiner says they're still dialed up to 11

Russell Crowe tipped for second Oscar with ‘powerhouse’ performance in WWII epic