Only Murders in the Building review – does this show just need to die now?

There are still many things to love here, but the cracks are well and truly appearing. Too many moments feel laboured … and Meryl Streep should be kept away from comedyIn the mid-90s, Bonnie and Terry Turner created a TV sitcom about a group of aliens (led by John Lithgow as their self-regarding High Commander) on a research mission to Earth. As they attempted to integrate into human life by posing as an ordinary family, gentle, charming hilarity ensued for six seasons – an unexpectedly long time, and 3rd Rock from the Sun became known as “the show they couldn’t cancel”. The fondness everyone felt for it endured past the show’s technical peak and kept it on our screens until the commercial inviability became too stark and/or the actors’ interest in participating waned. It was a rare pocket of sentimentality in the otherwise ruthless world of television programming.Only Murders in the Building is in all respects a much better show than 3rd Rock. It manages to fold in a cosy whodunnit, social media satire, zippy one-liners, sight gags, physical comedy and intergenerational friendships and commentary. An undertow of melancholy is ameliorated by optimism as its trio of main characters bond over their love of true-crime podcasts, then start their own, forging connections with the assorted misfits in the apartment building they live in, and the wider world. But as the fifth season begins, the memory of 3rd Rock begins to come back to me more strongly. Continue reading...

Comments

Culture

Anastacia says Arnold Schwarzenegger made her sing a cover 12 times for his birthday

Independent

Comments

Culture

Anastacia says Arnold Schwarzenegger made her sing a cover 12 times for his birthday

Jehnny Beth: ‘It took me years to understand my sexuality or even put a name on it’

Michael Palin held at gunpoint while making new documentary

Cillian Murphy relieved not to be in Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey

Breaking Bad actor Raymond Cruz arrested after allegedly spraying water at woman

The Darkness guitarist Dan Hawkins brands Yungblud’s Ozzy Osbourne tribute ‘cynical and nauseating’

Sydney Sweeney ‘absolutely loved’ gaining 30 pounds to play pro boxer in new biopic

A Single Man at the Royal Ballet & Opera review: a butt-wiggling celebration of gay love

Comedy legend, 82, held at gunpoint by police: ‘Things got quite heavy’

‘Captivating’ TV crime drama by Mare of Easttown creator launches on streaming

BBC boss admits ‘there may be more things coming out’ after scandals

Catherine Zeta-Jones branded ‘creepy’ after making inappropriate comment about underage fan

Blake Lively wants Justin Baldoni to pay millions of dollars for filing frivolous defamation suit

Gigi Hadid says she took singing lessons during fashion month to audition for Disney film

12 awful performances in brilliant movies, from Jake Gyllenhaal to Hugh Grant

MasterChef confirms all-female presenting team as Gregg Wallace and John Torode replacements

Charlie Sheen says Matthew Perry ‘used humor as a deflector-shield’

Charlie Sheen reveals reason he swapped surname from Estevez: ‘I wasn’t ashamed of the name’

Allen Blickle, former drummer for metal band Baroness, dies aged 42

Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson reveals real reason behind dramatic new physique: ‘Excited to transform again’

Daniel Craig earns praise for ‘electric’ performance in new Knives Out sequel

She was the queen of the spiritual memoir – so how did Elizabeth Gilbert end up plotting to murder her girlfriend?

Classic children’s TV character set for comeback 50 years after debut

Freddie Flintoff showered with praise as ‘refreshing’ Field of Dreams show returns

The White Lotus composer wins Emmy after dispute with show’s creator

Today Show cast shake up as long-time contributor announces departure

Stuart Craig, Oscar-winner who worked on Harry Potter, dies aged 83

Stephen King names the one ‘dangerous’ Trump scenario that scares him

Succession secured: Murdoch family reach deal over future of media empire

Children's TV favourite Bagpuss to reawaken for new film

Trump cheers West Point for ‘smartly’ cancelling awards ceremony for ‘WOKE’ Tom Hanks

Daniel Craig earning praise for ‘electric’ performance in new Knives Out sequel

Stephen King reveals his 10 favorite movies

Michael Caine, 92, to return for Last Witch Hunter sequel with Vin Diesel

Classic children’s character Bagpuss to make big screen return

BBC confirms major change to Strictly for first time in 21 years

Graham Linehan: I don't regret my online posts

Rick Davies, Singer and Co-Founder of Supertramp, Dies at 81

Britain’s National Gallery Expands Collection to 20th-Century Works

Sir Michael Caine, 92, comes out of retirement for surprise role with action icon

Sydney Sweeney reveals why she ‘absolutely loved’ her physical transformation for Christy film

Emma Thompson’s daughter was ‘very excited’ for them to star in film together

Every time Brian Cox has blasted Nigel Farage after labelling him a ‘bully’

Murdochs reach deal in succession battle, cementing conservative lean

Mirror and Express owner to cut over 300 jobs

What's the world's best apple? We asked an 'expert'

Book Review: ‘Listening to the Law,’ by Amy Coney Barrett

5 Highlights From Christoph von Dohnanyi’s Recording Career

With Task, the Mare of Easttown writer has another hit on his hands

New Banksy artwork to be removed from Royal Courts of Justice

New teen thriller 'Sisters in the Wind' finds drama in hidden identities

Highlights from the VMAs, from Mariah Carey's first win to Lady Gaga's magic act

Hollywood Actors and Directors Pledge to Boycott Israeli Film Institutions

5 Highlights From Christoph von Dohnanyi’s Recording Career

Teen Titans actor claims he was fired by Warner Bros after going public with Parkinson’s diagnosis

Taika Waititi and Rita Ora to turn Fyre Festival fiasco into a stage musical

Today cast shake up as long-time contributor announces departure

MasterChef confirms Grace Dent and Anna Haugh are replacing Gregg Wallace and John Torode

Actress claims shocking incident caused her to quit ‘one of the biggest shows on TV’

Harpist Brandee Younger embraces a broad range of jazz on 'Gadabout Season'