Train Dreams review – Joel Edgerton superb in Malickian story of trees, grief and railroads

A logger clears a path for change in this sunset-hour-tastic adaptation by Clint Bentley – clearly a director of considerable power and feelingThe dreams of the title are premonitions of the future, memories of the past, yearnings for an alternative present – and sometimes just the dreams that disturb the sleep of the film’s lead character, a logger named Robert Grainier, richly and expressively played with few words by Joel Edgerton. He is part of an exploited itinerant labour force in the early 20th century who cleared woodland wildernesses, built bridges and made way for the American railroad. He lives a quasi-hobo existence but is possessed of a passionate, unspoken inner life to which this fine movie gives expression. His emotional life is the tree that falls in the forest without making a sound.Greg Kwedar has adapted the 2011 novella by Denis Johnson; the director is Clint Bentley, and they have created a lovely looking, deeply felt film, clearly absorbing the influences of Terrence Malick in some of the low camera positions, sunset-hour compositions, narrative voiceovers, and epiphanically revealed glories of the American landscape. There is also something of the early work of David Gordon Green, a film-maker once considered an heir to Malick. Continue reading...

Comments

Culture

Alan Carr surprised by psychologist’s prediction for his performance on Celebrity Traitors

Independent

Comments

Similar News

Sombr, 20, hits back at ‘bodyshaming hate train’ after concertgoer’s brutal rant

George MacKay: ‘I trained as a Cornish fisherman with Callum Turner – it’s tough work’

Actors trained during pandemic lack vocal power and range, says RSC leader

Lewis Cope: ‘Calling me professionally trained is insulting to Strictly pros’

Rosie Jones: Police investigating after wine thrown at comedian in ‘ableist and homophobic’ attack on train

Culture

Alan Carr surprised by psychologist’s prediction for his performance on Celebrity Traitors

Inside the Celebrity Traitors castle: A wedding venue once owned by an opium trader

Traitors winner shares how to master ultimate game of deceit

Kate Garraway reveals Tom Daley knitting her a gift featuring Celebrity Traitors catchphrase

Nick Mohammed: The loveable Faithful and puzzle-master on The Celebrity Traitors

How Cat Burn’s quiet confidence got her to the Celebrity Traitors final

David Olusoga: The gentle questioning historian who’s made it to the Celebrity Traitors final

Celebrity Traitors in chaos as final episode ‘leaks’ online

Joe Marler: The burly rugby star turned ‘genius’ Faithful leader

Alan Carr: The most unlikely unsuspected Celebrity Traitor of all

Death by Lightning: The unbelievable true story of James Garfield’s presidency and assassination

Eddie Marsan says people like Laurence Fox fear ‘level playing field’ in acting

Millie Bobby Brown was ‘crying every day’ after cruel coverage of her outfits

Uma Thurman warned famous actress daughter about Quentin Tarantino’s ‘foot fetish’

Big Brother star Ben Duncan, who attended university with Prince William, dies after fall from luxury London hotel

The Celebrity Traitors winner leaks online after huge TV schedule mistake

Tory MP blasts GMB’s Kate Garraway during fiery David Lammy exchange

Death by Lightning review – A presidential assassination drama that probably won’t make history

Meghan Markle reportedly returning to acting after 8-year hiatus

The Night Manager season two: First images show Tom Hiddleston and Olivia Colman’s return after nine years

Debra Messing faces backlash after sharing meme calling Zohran Mamdani an ‘America-hating jihadist’

Ed Sheeran praised by Keir Starmer as government announces changes to music education in UK schools

Jimmy Kimmel launches food drive as Trump officials slash SNAP benefits

Jennifer Lawrence and Emma Stone join forces for Miss Piggy movie

BBC viewers left in floods of tears by ‘one of the most beautiful series they’ve seen’

Judge tosses Blake Lively’s claims against social media guru after Justin Baldoni lawsuit ends

Netflix hit K-Pop Demon Hunters sets release date for sequel

Paul Hollywood says Great British Bake Off 2025 winner is ‘best in a while’

Acting has been taken over by 'posh boys', says Eddie Marsan

Aimee Lou Wood: ‘I feel like I can take ownership of what I need to thrive’

Cat Burns addresses Lucy Beaumont friendship after comedian ‘wasn’t happy’ with Celebrity Traitors murder

Shetland is back – with a bombshell

Meghan Markle set to ‘play herself’ in return to acting after 8 years

A Zohran Mamdani Ad Used a Bob Dylan Song. The Music Was Removed.

The Shutdown of U.S.A.I.D. Has Already Killed Hundreds of Thousands

Judge tosses Blake Lively’s claims against social media guru after Justin Baldoni lawsuit ends

Danielle Fishel’s husband shares picture of actor with IV after emotional exit from DWTS

Netflix hit K-Pop Demon Hunters sets release date for sequel

Jade Thirlwall opens up on time with Little Mix: ‘It was cut-throat’

Jennifer Lawrence says she is working on a Miss Piggy film with Emma Stone

Strictly faces scandal with ‘married celebrity kissing pro dancer in secret video’

UK girl group icon shares fears she was ‘too old’ to start solo career

Salman Rushdie’s Literary Inspirations

Jade Thirlwall says being in Little Mix was ‘cut-throat’

All's Fair: Is Kim Kardashian poking fun at Taylor Swift in her new legal drama?

Harry Potter TV series ‘makes major change from movies’ – and fans aren’t so sure

Joey Barton's posts 'caused me sleepless nights', says Jeremy Vine

Judge orders White House to use American Sign Language interpreters at briefings

'It's as if I've been reborn': Misty Copeland begins a next chapter in 'a new body'

A child disappears from a playdate and it's 'All Her Fault' in this gripping TV series

‘Girl, Interrupted,’ With Aimee Mann Songs, to Be Staged in New York

I was looking forward to Stranger Things – but David Harbour has given me the ick

Grammys 2026: Everything you need to know about the voting process

Jennifer Lawrence and Emma Stone join forces for Miss Piggy movie

All's Fair review: don't be square, this deranged Kim Kardashian vehicle is a drag queen fever dream

Millie Bobby Brown says adopting with Jake Bongiovi has been ‘beautiful’ journey

Rapper detained in murder investigation of influencer

It’s Cool to Have No Followers Now

Jimmy Kimmel launches food drive as Trump officials slash SNAP benefits

Ex-American Idol contestant arrested on suspicion of having sex with a minor