Even the Tories now admit that our electoral system is toxic. When will Labour have the guts to fix it? | Polly Toynbee

Giving 16-year-olds the vote is good, not least to stop the rightward lurch, but real change would mean scrapping first past the post“Gerrymandering!” cry those on the right. But the government’s plan for voting reform, which will allow 16- and 17-year-olds to vote in the next general election, isn’t to Labour’s advantage. Voters of this age are unlikely to favour the incumbent government they have grown up with. Though lowering the voting age was a manifesto promise, real electoral reform was nowhere in the manifesto. Real reform would mean abolishing the broken, discredited, untrusted and unsafe first-past-the-post system.Keir Starmer often promises to put country before party. But as this year’s British Social Attitudes survey found, only 12% of people trust governments to put the country’s interest before their own party’s. Labour can prove them wrong by fixing a fragile democracy in grave danger. It needs moral nerve to admit the system that elected it – allowing Labour to win 64% of seats with just 34% of votes – lacks legitimacy. In the words of the Electoral Reform Society, the 2024 result was “not only the most disproportional election in British electoral history, but one of the most disproportional seen anywhere in the world”.Polly Toynbee is a Guardian columnist Continue reading...

Comments

Similar News

The wild risk so many wives are taking that could END their marriages - and the worst part is, they don't even class what they're doing as cheating: TRACEY COX

Why even a three-Test rout against Australia won't place this Lions squad among the pantheon of greats - but here's what Andy Farrell and Co can do to make a lasting statement Down Under, writes CHRIS FOY

Contributor: Trump's MAGA spell is broken. Even his base knows he is a lame duck

Contributor: Even if you think Sean Combs is guilty, his conviction should give you pause

Afghans have been betrayed yet again by this shocking UK data leak – and many don’t even know if they’re affected | Diane Taylor

Even centrists want to vote for Reform

Pathetic: Top US Democrats don’t even dare denounce Zohran Mamdani’s extremism

When he agreed to my bold request after our first date, I got the instant ick. He's the first man to fall for my trick... even though every woman does it: JANE GREEN

Pregnancy Is Going to Be Even More Dangerous in America

Even loyal Labour MPs now call for “radical change” to avert “political disaster”

ASML finds even monopolists get the blues

Take a political time-out, Elon Musk: ‘America Party’ rant proves even your genius has its limits

Contributor: The scars from unrest can run deep, for protesters, residents and even authorities

Nanny state, for real: Feds won’t even trust parents with a baby pillow

Iran’s devastation has hardened hearts towards the west – even for those with no love of the state | Hossein Hamdieh

Letters to the Editor: Even if strikes were successful, that doesn't mean Iran's nuclear ambitions are gone

HENRY DEEDES: Even on holiday in the heavenly Greek island of Kefalonia there's no escaping mobile morons

AMANDA PLATELL: The crude betrayal at the heart of the England Lionesses that could ruin their Euros campaign before it even begins

Opinions

The huge problem with Australia's so-called First Nations Ambassador - and it's not just the massive travel bill that's raising eyebrows

PETER VAN ONSELEN: Virtue-signalling Labor slaps a 'plaque of shame' under Mark Latham - but what about Gough, Bob, Billy and Arthur?

As Prince George turns 12, why Kate and William have been urged to ensure safety of future King after Charles's concerns: RICHARD EDEN'S DIARY

Stephen Colbert fans’ cancellation hysteria takes Trump Derangement Syndrome to the max

CBS’s long-awaited Colbert cancellation: Letters to the Editor — July 22, 2025

Trump is stacking wins, voters reject Dems’ left turn and other commentary

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Fake Or Fortune? on BBC1: Was this £140 market find really a priceless painting by Churchill?

Zohran Mamdani’s disdain for the law is disqualifying — and dangerous

‘Killer’s’ tossed guilty verdict over snoozing pal’s ejection from court should keep New Yorkers up at night

It’s way past time for Mayor Adams to lift the NYPD bans on facial-ID tech

Will NY pols finally come to their senses after shooting of CBP agent by an illegal immigrant?

Dem leaders who won’t speak out against Mamdani don’t deserve to hold office

Former Rep. Marjorie Margolies on how motherhood prepared her for Congress

America’s message to laid-off feds: We feel for you, but we’re broke

Manifold problems at BP: New boss must restore confidence at board level and with investors, says MAGGIE PAGANO

I ran Britain's riskiest parkrun - inside a jail with 20 prisoners. This is the extraordinary story and why so many runners are desperate to do it, writes OLIVER HOLT

Anthony Albanese's office photo: What's in, what's out and what it says about Australia's leader in 2025... including the item we can all relate to

Contributor: My last garden

I have lost 3st on Mounjaro and now my hair is falling out: DR MARTIN SCURR reveals the troubling cause - and shares a NEW jab side effect everyone is missing

I received a DWP text about claiming Winter Fuel Payment - is it real? STEVE WEBB issues scam alert

Democrats bow to nuclear-energy reality — but the left won’t give up their delusions

Miranda Devine: Trump wins the Epstein battle — as the left, media foolishly believe prez on the skids

When WILL this serpentine creature now given such power by Starmer be forced to answer for his actions?: STEPHEN GLOVER

Marco Rubio’s sanctions on a key UN antisemite may already be paying dividends

City Council lefties tackle ‘affordability’ by driving up grocery prices. Brilliant

Bomber pilot spills on what it’s like to fly a mission: ‘No time to be afraid’

‘Iraq Syndrome’ is dead, why PBS & NPR had to go and other commentary

The city and state’s fiscal pain just got real —and it was all so avoidable

How I save over $600 on my 'recession nails' whilst still enjoying luxe manicures: POLISHED with Elise Wilson

MAUREEN CALLAHAN: Hoda Kotb's shameless exploitation of her OWN kids makes her latest 'morning show' hustle all the more revolting

Britain waves the white flag to Islamization and illegal immigration

Vladimir Putin throws a tyrant tantrum — but Russia is big, brutish and bluffing

Mamdani would make New York a gloomy city of handouts and moochers

DEAR JANE: My female bestie has become a third in my relationship. Her barefoot obsession drives my boyfriend crazy

Trump’s party-splitting Epstein dilemma: Letters to the Editor — July 21, 2025

Trump defied the world with truth — and upended the status quo

Why even a three-Test rout against Australia won't place this Lions squad among the pantheon of greats - but here's what Andy Farrell and Co can do to make a lasting statement Down Under, writes CHRIS FOY

SARAH VINE: Why is 16 too young for voting? Ask a brain scientist...

The unwatchably awful Stephen Colbert interview that proves why he was doomed: MAUREEN CALLAHAN delivers the real story... and unmasks America's most loathsome late-night host

FLOURISHING AFTER 50: I bought a house with my son - and now I'm paying for everything

TONY HETHERINGTON: Dad's £54,000 van has a brake fault but he can't get a refund

I did something awful in an Uber after my fiancé left the club early... He knew the truth the moment I kissed him when I got home: ASK JANA

I loathe Latham - and he hates me back. But there's an important detail about those vile allegations his critics in parliament have chosen to ignore. Do I really have to spell it out? PVO

PETER HITCHENS: Ukraine's the stupidest war in modern history. Darkness is closing in

The Biden administration secretly stole your data to engineer elections and silence speech

DAN HODGES: Keir Starmer's delusional if he thinks his morally bankrupt plan to let 16-year-olds vote will help him out. They'll NEVER vote for him

Don’t expect Zohran Mamdani — or any other mayoral candidate — to fix NYC’s troubled schools

Letters to the Editor: Trump might be right to pull funding for California's 'train to nowhere'

Trump deserves a decision on his fraud-ruling appeal — free of political foot-dragging

ALISON BOSHOFF: Market it like Meghan Markle! Duchess hopes to flog her brand...in the mall

What Snoop Dogg's weird and offbeat investment really means for Swansea - and the worrying truth behind clubs welcoming celebrities in, writes RIATH AL-SAMARRAI

Is consuming dairy like milk and cheese the cause of my bedtime problems? DR ELLIE reveals the surprising answer - and the cure

AMANDA PLATELL: This is the real scandal at the heart of the BBC that we are all being manipulated into ignoring. John Torode's sacking is just a distraction

Dimon’s delusional Powell support and more: Letters to the Editor — July 20, 2025

My best friend won't stop moaning, everything becomes a 'misery contest'. Should I walk away? This letter writer's more sad than they admit, replies BEL MOONEY... here's why

JESSICA BOULTON: Only one BBC icon's been UNFAIRLY 'cancelled' this week - and it's not John Torode

BORIS JOHNSON: Why Trump's really turning against Putin and Ukraine can now dare to dream of victory again

Voters’ Zohran Mamdani fears: Letters to the Editor — July 19, 2025

Perps with HUNDREDS of arrests make a mockery of New York’s criminal-justice system