Labour alienated its core and failed to attract Reform voters. Now will Starmer change tack? | John McDonnell

The local elections showed that voters feel betrayed. But in a party that brooks no dissent, that message isn’t getting throughJohn McDonnell was shadow chancellor for Labour from 2015 to 2020The response from Labour spokespeople so far to the loss of Runcorn and Helsby – and to the election results as a whole – has been especially tin-eared. There doesn’t seem to be any understanding of the deep-seated emotion in the reaction of Labour supporters to the party’s behaviour in government over the past 10 months. There used to be talk of the need for emotional literacy in politics. What we are witnessing is a staggering level of emotional illiteracy.Labour supporters feel deeply that their party has turned its back on them. It’s not just that they feel they are not being listened to. It’s that the Starmer and Reeves government is doing things that they believe no Labour government should ever do.John McDonnell is the independent MP for Hayes and Harlington. He was shadow chancellor for Labour from 2015 to 2020 Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

Ink trade deals ASAP to avoid a downward economic AND political spiral

PETER VAN ONSELEN: Now for 'Albo the Almighty's' revolution: What to REALLY expect from the next three years from an emboldened PM... and who's getting knifed

about 4 hours ago

Despite their denials, China is losing the tariffs war and retreating as fast as it can

What will happen if Peter Dutton loses his seat as Labor insiders grow quietly confident behind the scenes, writes PETER VAN ONSELEN

about 13 hours ago

I have a 2000 Apple iMac DV with original packaging - will it grow in value if I keep it? DAN HATFIELD replies

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: Baronet's daughter who shocked guests when she stripped down to her lingerie at wedding reception has the smart set talking with rather eccentric choice of baby names...

about 23 hours ago

RICHARD EDEN: New romance blooms for Lord Cowdray, 80, two years after bitter split from mother of his six children

Albo's successor revealed: Daily Mail Ipsos poll reveals the surprising Labor figure who Australia wants to succeed the PM ... if election 2025 goes badly

1 day ago

Harvard faculty vow to tithe -- but not to God

Forget a pact with Reform - this is who Kemi Badenoch should go into coalition with to fight off Farage's forces: SARAH VINE

1 day ago

This is the beginning of the end for Starmer - the suit so generously purchased for him by Lord Alli has been branded with the yellow stripe of betrayal: DAN HODGES

1 day ago

Bruno Fernandes has gone from unsuitable Man United captain to their 'glue' and 'social connector'... he deserves to be the player of the season, writes IAN LADYMAN

1 day ago

Herald Diary: Prepare yourself for a very dark Rebus novel

MAUREEN CALLAHAN dares to say the unutterable about Bill Belichick and Jordon Hudson's 49-year age gap... but it's what you're thinking too!

2 days ago

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: As Ed Miliband doubles down on his Net Zero madness… Disaster, my friend, is blowin' in the wind

2 days ago

TOM UTLEY: Mrs U's £55 parking fine meant that, for once, SHE looked silly. I paid up - it was cheap at the price for the joy of seeing her blush!

2 days ago

What to know about Paula White-Cain and the White House Faith office

2 days ago

Comments

Similar News

Why it’s now Reform vs Labour

Letters: Want rid of SNP and Labour? Learn a lesson from England

ALEX BRUMMER: Labour's paralysis on growth is galling

Martin Rowson on Reform UK’s defeat of Labour in the Runcorn byelection – cartoon

Is Farage’s win a new dawn? We could ask Labour, but they’re still fast asleep | Marina Hyde

Reform’s Runcorn victory is a warning to Labour

How winter fuel cost Labour these elections

Reform wins: dire for Labour, existential for Tories

Mark McGeoghegan: Doubling down on Reform could be Labour's biggest mistake

Labour's postal sell-out: Did we learn nothing from the financial vandalism of our water firms? asks ALEX BRUMMER

The Guardian view on Labour and net zero politics: lean in and ignore bad advice | Editorial

Labour must rethink killer-blow tax raid on struggling bookies or face voters’ wrath

Premier League under threat from new football regulator & Labour is about to score mother of all own goals

The Tories have shown Labour exactly how not to fight Farage | Rafael Behr

Why is Labour getting bolder on Europe? It knows even leave voters can now see the benefits | Gaby Hinsliff

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: Labour's lying to us about migration. They're planning to flood the country with EU 'youths' and it's freedom of movement by the front door

Labour and Conservatives face a challenging electoral test | Letters

The Green Party: ‘We are willing to stand with people. We are different to Labour’

A Tory government outbidding Labour on tax rises isn't sensible economics writes MARK LITTLEWOOD

Keir Starmer brags that his dad was a toolmaker - so why is he taxing us out of existence? Craftsmen like PM's father hammer Labour over crippling Budget

Opinions

Ink trade deals ASAP to avoid a downward economic AND political spiral

Disaster is coming, and the solution to healing is community — not chaos

Letters to the Editor: President Trump's cuts to climate scientists are among his most consequential

PETER VAN ONSELEN: Now for 'Albo the Almighty's' revolution: What to REALLY expect from the next three years from an emboldened PM... and who's getting knifed

Despite their denials, China is losing the tariffs war and retreating as fast as it can

Steve Witkoff’s diplomatic failures and more: Letters to the Editor — May 4, 2025

Now is the time for NASA to blast into a new future — after slowing to a crawl

Face facts and pull the plug on NY’s insane electric-vehicle mandate

Guy Stenhouse: We must face the Big Four issues, and start doing something

Canada’s new leader is bad for Canada — and the US

How do you navigate through a Legal Aid desert?

'There is nothing wrong with taking a stand against Israel's genocide and occupation'

Gregor Gall: Holyrood is not the people's parliament - it is run by a Scottish elite

Herald Diary: So what's the difference between Lego and a bottle of wine?

What will happen if Peter Dutton loses his seat as Labor insiders grow quietly confident behind the scenes, writes PETER VAN ONSELEN

I have a 2000 Apple iMac DV with original packaging - will it grow in value if I keep it? DAN HATFIELD replies

Letters: Want rid of SNP and Labour? Learn a lesson from England

Brian Taylor: Will Reform’s Runcorn victory translate into Scottish success?

Mark Smith: Another student tower rises. But what does it mean for the rest of us?

Camley's Cartoon on Trump's Turnberry hopes

Trump deregulation effort quietly kills obnoxious Biden-era appliance schemes

Trump’s ‘big, beautiful’ budget plan delivers for America

DAILY MAIL COMMENT: Is era of two-party politics at an end?

Who’s driving this donkey? Losing Dems need a moderate pivot, but radical left steering for a cliff

To force Putin to end his war on Ukraine, give Kyiv the weapons it needs

Kristi Noem’s question-raising rob: Letters to the Editor — May 3, 2025

The key to building Trump’s new American Golden Age

Yale profs fight back, we need higher tariffs on China and other commentary

Does Keir Starmer have the team-talk in him to turn it all around after Reform’s shuddering victory?

ALEX BRUMMER: Labour's paralysis on growth is galling

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: Baronet's daughter who shocked guests when she stripped down to her lingerie at wedding reception has the smart set talking with rather eccentric choice of baby names...

RICHARD EDEN: New romance blooms for Lord Cowdray, 80, two years after bitter split from mother of his six children

We may have to buy everything from trains to shoes from China, but there is something Brits will NEVER be beaten at

Brown student Alex Shieh is over the target on BS jobs and DEI— so the school is going after him

Tim Walz’s goofy ‘revelation’ speaks volumes about Democrats’ identity-politics fixation

New Yorkers get slammed yet again by a state budget that LITERALLY robs them blind

BORIS JOHNSON: The Tories CAN win the next election - here's how...

Jude - here's what you can learn from Lamine Yamal, writes GRAEME SOUNESS

Letter to the editor: We could have won Vietnam

Letter to the editor: Declaration of Independence unites us

Neil Mackay: English nationalism will be the death of the union

Albo's successor revealed: Daily Mail Ipsos poll reveals the surprising Labor figure who Australia wants to succeed the PM ... if election 2025 goes badly

Harvard faculty vow to tithe -- but not to God

Letter to the editor: Left's logic-defying agenda

Letters: Will we ever see real action on chronic pain and drug deaths?

Contributor: Take it from California's election czar, the SAVE Act is a sham

Forget a pact with Reform - this is who Kemi Badenoch should go into coalition with to fight off Farage's forces: SARAH VINE

This is the beginning of the end for Starmer - the suit so generously purchased for him by Lord Alli has been branded with the yellow stripe of betrayal: DAN HODGES

Bruno Fernandes has gone from unsuitable Man United captain to their 'glue' and 'social connector'... he deserves to be the player of the season, writes IAN LADYMAN

Herald Diary: Prepare yourself for a very dark Rebus novel

Scammers stole £5,608 from my Wise business account: Can I get it back? CRANE ON THE CASE

Andy Maciver: Tony Blair is right: we need to rip up net zero and start again

Mark McGeoghegan: Doubling down on Reform could be Labour's biggest mistake

Letters: The public has the right to an inquiry into the ferries fiasco

Ian McConnell: Flights joy for Scottish airport on key routes

LOVERRO: Capitals get over the first-round playoff hump

MAUREEN CALLAHAN dares to say the unutterable about Bill Belichick and Jordon Hudson's 49-year age gap... but it's what you're thinking too!