Nuclear non-proliferation is a failure in the Middle East | Letters

Unless Israel is open about its nuclear weapons and joins the non-proliferation treaty, Iran will one day have the bomb, writes Corrado Pirzio-Biroli. Plus, letters by Hubert Cassel, Dr Anthony Isaacs and Randhir Singh BainsI agree with Simon Tisdall’s opinion (Trump, Netanyahu and Khamenei, three angry old men who could get us all killed, 15 June). The reckless decisions of these leaders did not take place in a vacuum. As Tisdall writes: “The roots of major conflicts often reach back decades – and this is true of the Israel-Iran vendetta, which dates to the 1979 Islamic revolution.” I suggest reaching further back to the 1950s, when Israel built its nuclear facility in Dimona and Charles De Gaulle decided to end French support unless Israel joined the non‑proliferation treaty (NPT).After John F Kennedy’s ultimatum for safeguards, Israel accepted six inspections, until Richard Nixon and Henry Kissinger condoned its nuclear status outside the NPT, provided Israel maintained nuclear ambiguity, playing down its strategic advantage. Israel concealed its nuclear status, refused to adhere to the NPT as contrary to its national security interest, and adopted the “Begin doctrine” of counter-proliferation, envisaging preventive strikes against Middle Eastern countries installing nuclear reactors that might produce nuclear weapons. Accordingly, it destroyed Iraq’s and Syria’s nuclear reactors (in 1981 and 2007 respectively) and, in cooperation with the US, damaged the Iranian nuclear facilities with the Stuxnet malware (which leaked and spread). Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

Operation Rising Lion: An opening for Trump's big, beautiful Iran deal

washington times

MAUREEN CALLAHAN: The truth of Brad Pitt cruelly disowning his children that Jennifer Aniston warned us all about it... 20 years ago

about 4 hours ago

New evidence on the dangers of child sex changes

washington times

What Palace insiders tell me about Kate's sudden absence from Ascot, reveals RICHARD EDEN - as intrigue deepens over 'friends' detail everyone's missed

about 11 hours ago

Dailymail

Parents SHOULD be fined for taking children on holiday during term time says LEE BOYCE - here's three ideas to help families have a cheaper break

about 12 hours ago

New Statesman

Hold onto your wallets, Australia - more taxes are on their way! The clue that radical economic change is coming: PETER VAN ONSELEN

about 16 hours ago

I lost my car keys on an Avanti train but it told me they were at a VETS: CRANE ON THE CASE

Dailymail

TV star's extreme parenting move she's too scared to tell other mums, director's savage comment on nepo baby star, plus which politician is making an eye-watering £55k an HOUR exposed: RICHARD EDEN'S DIARY

about 21 hours ago

JENNI MURRAY: Those paid to protect children must stop being scared of racism accusations and tell us what they know

Dailymail

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: Dragons' Den star Sara Davies reveals her drastic rule for children who come to her home for play dates

about 22 hours ago

Dailymail

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews: Long Lost Family: Born Without Trace: Davina's DNA search show's been left behind by the march of science

about 22 hours ago

ROBERT HARDMAN: Gleaming George is back in Trafalgar Square... and still standing on U.S. soil

Dailymail

Comments

Similar News

America Can’t Bomb Iran Out of Making a Nuclear Weapon

Israel is doing the world a favor – now the US must give any help necessary to end Iran’s nuclear threat

A look inside the president’s nuclear war briefcase

Israel cleared the way, but only Trump can end Iran’s nuclear program

The Guardian view on Israel, the US and Iran: you can’t bomb your way out of nuclear proliferation | Editorial

Only one American can start a nuclear war: The president

Best of the Babylon Bee: Have experience in nuclear engineering? Check out Iran’s new job openings

A Nuclear Deal Is Still Possible

I don't get it: why can't Iran be allowed to have nuclear weapons?

Iran’s lies about its nuclear plans finally at an end

Spending billions on unclean, risky energy? What a nuclear waste | Letters

Tulsi Gabbard gave a nuclear-hot take. Good effort — but I have notes.

Israel is serving the entire world — taking huge risks to stop Iran from going nuclear

The Guardian view on Iran’s nuclear programme: Trump undid a crucial accord. A new deal is urgently needed | Editorial

Oops! Nuclear war!

How nuclear war could start

Labour loves nuclear power. The SNP hates it - and maybe, just maybe, they are right

The Guardian view on Labour’s nuclear bet: big promises, but bigger questions remain unanswered | Editorial

Britain has escalated the global nuclear arms race – and is bringing us closer to armageddon | Simon Tisdall

Fresh grounds to snap back Iran sanctions — and block it from getting a nuclear bomb

Opinions

Operation Rising Lion: An opening for Trump's big, beautiful Iran deal

A youthful rush to revive America

It's time to rip the mask off abusive hospital pricing

Democrats and media want to normalize the L.A. riots because they have lost the immigration argument

Liberal protests against Trump alienate the mainstream

NYers’ miserable options for mayor: Letters to the Editor — June 20, 2025

QUENTIN LETTS: Lucy the Leader rabbits away snippily. Can No 10 not find someone better?

MAUREEN CALLAHAN: The truth of Brad Pitt cruelly disowning his children that Jennifer Aniston warned us all about it... 20 years ago

New evidence on the dangers of child sex changes

Letter to the editor: Invaders, not "undocumented immigrants"

What does an abuser playing Scotland's national stadium say about us?

This extreme metal album blew up over a weekend – now it's accused of being AI

The alleged fairness of the SQA? An extra 15 minutes for a Higher English exam

Letters to the Editor: More needs to be done to keep ICE agents accountable to the law

On the hottest day of the year it's brass monkeys at our house thanks to British Gas: RICHARD LITTLEJOHN

Letter to the editor: Karen Read jury likely acted in self-interest

Letter to the editor: Padilla wanted a performance, not answers

Energy storage must not be overlooked on the road to net zero

What Team Trump must do to get deportations right

Letters to the Editor: As concerns arise around ICE and racial profiling, 'Could it happen to me?'

Letters to the Editor: The resurgence of downtown is some much-needed good news for L.A.

Tennessee wins big to protect children from LGBTQ evil

Why our politicians must declare a mental health emergency

Trump, the world's No1 ignoramus, is out to destroy the rules-based world order

What Palace insiders tell me about Kate's sudden absence from Ascot, reveals RICHARD EDEN - as intrigue deepens over 'friends' detail everyone's missed

Parents SHOULD be fined for taking children on holiday during term time says LEE BOYCE - here's three ideas to help families have a cheaper break

Princess Diana’s kinder Britain

He wears it well: How Rod Stewart is still getting steamy at 80

You're wasting your breath, Mr Swinney: we don't need another conversation

If Scots classrooms are in chaos, teachers need the option of expelling worst pupils

Getting rid of the two child cap is a small part of the bigger picture

The Herald cartoon on Putin and Iran

Hold onto your wallets, Australia - more taxes are on their way! The clue that radical economic change is coming: PETER VAN ONSELEN

I lost my car keys on an Avanti train but it told me they were at a VETS: CRANE ON THE CASE

Israel is doing the world a favor – now the US must give any help necessary to end Iran’s nuclear threat

Miranda Devine: FBI emails revealed to The Post expose Biden DOJ’s obsession with piling on Trump charges

Now it's Labour's turn to face the music when global events turn sour: ALEX BRUMMER

TV star's extreme parenting move she's too scared to tell other mums, director's savage comment on nepo baby star, plus which politician is making an eye-watering £55k an HOUR exposed: RICHARD EDEN'S DIARY

JENNI MURRAY: Those paid to protect children must stop being scared of racism accusations and tell us what they know

From abortion to assisted dying, why does the Left seem so keen on killing people? STEPHEN GLOVER

Keep the focus on stopping Iran’s nukes — ‘regime change’ is too risky a game

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: Dragons' Den star Sara Davies reveals her drastic rule for children who come to her home for play dates

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews: Long Lost Family: Born Without Trace: Davina's DNA search show's been left behind by the march of science

ROBERT HARDMAN: Gleaming George is back in Trafalgar Square... and still standing on U.S. soil

From Tehran to Pyongyang: Dictators, beware Israel's resolve

Massachusetts federal judge forces government to endorse non-biological gender

Trump, war and the Constitution

How Trump can protect Americans from financial fraud

Postwar recovery of Ukraine: Challenges and opportunities

Make it beautiful: The 'one big bill' must respect state leadership

Subway crime starts at the turnstile — and every Democrat fails the test

Environmentalist goon squad Greenpeace learns a lesson

Twisting the truth: Extreme weather and the climate narrative

The resurgence of America's armed forces

ChatGPT reveals why it would embrace Christianity

Behind Trump’s Israel backing, leftist rot ruins universities and other commentary

Brad Lander’s ICE arrest stunt: Letters to the Editor — June 19, 2025