Republican Texas is a surprising model for solving the UK’s prison crisis – but it just might work | Gaby Hinsliff

Jails in England and Wales are in overcrowded meltdown, but justice secretary Shabana Mahmood has a rare chance to flip the script. She shouldWhat should become of the two idiots who took a chainsaw to the beloved Sycamore Gap tree? Obviously it was thuggish, a pointless desecration of something that gave countless people joy, judging by the outpouring of unexpectedly deep emotion that followed. Landscapes work their way into the soul. But so does the thought of two children whose father is about to be jailed for what the judge warned would be a “lengthy period”. Though a line obviously has to be drawn, is this really the best way we can think of to punish a heartless act that nonetheless posed no danger to human life?Now is the perfect time to wrestle with questions such as this, about whom we send to prison and why, and whether doing it differently would lead to a more humane but more effective prison system and ultimately cut crime. For this government is – shock, horror – finally about to do something liberals might actually like. Next week the justice secretary, Shabana Mahmood, is due to publish a review of sentencing commissioned from one of her Tory predecessors, David Gauke, expected among other things to recommend that inmates be allowed to earn freedom after serving only a third of their sentences by good behaviour, or by engaging with work and education that will help them get jobs on release. It’s something progressives have wanted for years but which government after government has nervously backed away from, fearful of being branded soft on crime – though the inspiration was tough, Republican-governed Texas, where reoffending rates have fallen by nearly a third since similar reforms were introduced. Unfortunately, a crisis left by the last government means this one now looks as if it’s not exactly acting out of choice.Gaby Hinsliff is a Guardian columnist Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

Insane progressive leniency keeps letting more young terrors skirt

Newyork Post

Cassie’s testimony against Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs revealed a monster worse than any of us realized — but is it enough to send him to prison?

about 11 hours ago

Supremes consider whether one district judge can derail a president

Newyork Post

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: We have turned our prisons into Love Island with female guards who look like the Kardashians. It's no wonder so many of them are having affairs with criminals

about 17 hours ago

Cole Palmer risks being trapped outside the elite with Chelsea - here's why his days there may be numbered

Dailymail

BRYONY GORDON: This week I suffered a horrific OCD episode that left me fearing I was a psychopath. This is how I dealt with it - after years of numbing my intrusive thoughts with drugs and alcohol

about 19 hours ago

the guardian

The 'truth' behind Kate Middleton's support for Victoria and David Beckham amid their feud with Brooklyn and Nicola Peltz, friends tell RICHARD EDEN

about 22 hours ago

Letters: Stop tinkering around the edges: we need a National Care Service, now

The Herald

Detained Bella May Culley's ordeal will be on so many parents' minds as their teenagers jet off on girls trips and lads holidays this summer

1 day ago

Herald Diary: Here's how to party like John Lennon

The Herald

STEPHEN GLOVER: Israel is a civilised democracy disfigured by a nasty government. I pray that Netanyahu and his allies aren't allowed to practise ethnic cleansing - so we can focus on the real villains

1 day ago

washington times

Now is the time to get the National Security Council right

1 day ago

Comments

Similar News

House Republicans are about to wreck Trump’s nuclear-powered dream

Republicans should look to states for budgeting model

How do Republicans plan to cut health coverage? Let us count the ways.

The Republican plan to bury Medicaid recipients in paperwork

To dodge a recession, congressional Republicans should speed Trump's tax cuts

Virginia GOP’s gay-porn disaster a lesson to Republicans: primaries matter

House Republicans take on Medicaid

How Republicans became America’s ‘de-growth’ party

Sorry Republicans, you can’t buy your way to more babies

Republicans’ budget would cut services Americans rely on most

As a midwestern Republican, I oppose gutting national service

House Republicans finally have corruption to investigate. They won’t.

Trump is fulfilling an education promise Republicans made for decades

Republicans don’t think Trump can ignore the Supreme Court — for now

A Republican Senator Says It: ‘We Are All Afraid’

Republicans need a backup plan on Trump’s tax cuts

Contributor: Americans are sick of federal waste. Republicans should take the hint

Opinions

Insane progressive leniency keeps letting more young terrors skirt

Diary: It's amazing what you have to be expert at these days...

Mark McGeoghegan: Starmer is no Enoch Powell, but he has got this so wrong

Letters: Time for change: CalMac cannot be the future of west coast ferry services

Andy Maciver: This week showed our MSPs can be better if we let them

Diddy, Cassie, & the anatomy of "mutual abuse"

Douglas Murray: Qatar’s ‘gestures’ to Trump raise suspicions on both ends of the political spectrum

QUENTIN LETTS: Volcanic Sir Lindsay's eruptions left hapless minister buried in ash

Americans want to move to Scotland— they might want to think twice

A federal takeover of Rikers Island jails is long overdue — and shouldn’t be delayed

Cassie’s testimony against Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs revealed a monster worse than any of us realized — but is it enough to send him to prison?

Supremes consider whether one district judge can derail a president

Trump offers incentives for illegal aliens to return to their home countries

Strategic international aid is the key to America's peace through strength

The week in whoppers: Publisher pretends NY Times is unbiased, Nancy Pelosi distorts GOP’s Medicaid plan and more

White South African refugees reveal partisan pundits’ true colors — and they’re ugly

Democrats are delusional to blame Biden for their election mess

Arab Israelis stand with their country — and reject the rage of Hamas

Starmer is learning the hard way that the EU is still hellbent on taking revenge for Brexit

Tax break boost for growth: Golden opportunity for Reeves to supercharge Britain's digital economy, says ALEX BRUMMER

America's China strategy needs urgent overhaul

America's GPS vulnerability threatens defense strategy

LOVERRO: The banishment of Pete Rose was about deterrence, and good luck with that now

Republicans should look to states for budgeting model

Trump torches neocon elite in the Middle East

Take American jobs back from China

Greedy water execs’ bonus scheme worth MILLIONS is outrageous – they’re filling pockets while pumping rivers with s**t

How the hell can prisons be full when proper criminals don’t get jailed anymore & paedos & groomers get soft sentences?

I'm Kevin and I'm a Catholic so why do I feel a certain empathy for the Orange Lodge?

Thanks to Netflix, you will never watch this episode of Black Mirror ever again

Air traffic controller union is … out of control

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: We have turned our prisons into Love Island with female guards who look like the Kardashians. It's no wonder so many of them are having affairs with criminals

Cole Palmer risks being trapped outside the elite with Chelsea - here's why his days there may be numbered

Letter to the editor: Menendez brothers' abuse claim disingenuous

Letter to the editor: Thorium for nuclear power

So Stacey Solomon didn’t win a Bafta? She should thank her lucky stars

The SNP reduced education targets and hoped no one would notice

Manhattan's West Village Girl plague has already spread to Scotland

Letters to the Editor: Is it right for insurance companies to charge more for others' losses?

PETER VAN ONSELEN: Here comes Labor's giant new super tax - and don't think it won't apply to you

BRYONY GORDON: This week I suffered a horrific OCD episode that left me fearing I was a psychopath. This is how I dealt with it - after years of numbing my intrusive thoughts with drugs and alcohol

Letter: Bill Ashton obituary

Letter to the editor: Freedom under political left is a joke

Media ought to quit whining about Trump

The 'truth' behind Kate Middleton's support for Victoria and David Beckham amid their feud with Brooklyn and Nicola Peltz, friends tell RICHARD EDEN

Letters: Stop tinkering around the edges: we need a National Care Service, now

It's time for Scotland to rethink women's healthcare

The Washington Post’s fact-challenged ‘Fact Checker’ is a propaganda mill

Detained Bella May Culley's ordeal will be on so many parents' minds as their teenagers jet off on girls trips and lads holidays this summer

Herald Diary: Here's how to party like John Lennon

Brian Wilson: The case for an accountable CalMac run by the people who depend on it

Letters: This is wrong: why are we sending out the message that some suicides are OK?

The agony of man who lost 38 years in jail for a crime he didn’t commit

The Herald cartoon on more potential ferry delays

'Orange Order's enemies are not found in the Catholic Church - they are in Holyrood'

Peter van Onselen: Australia can breathe easy after Greens go for the blandest option in Larissa 'Still' Waters

Does my mum have a fortune in a lost bond from 1972? CRANE ON THE CASE

Miranda Devine: The left tries to claim white South Africans aren’t worthy of refugee status

STEPHEN GLOVER: Israel is a civilised democracy disfigured by a nasty government. I pray that Netanyahu and his allies aren't allowed to practise ethnic cleansing - so we can focus on the real villains

Now is the time to get the National Security Council right