The Guardian view on Britain’s AI strategy: the risk is that it is dependency dressed up in digital hype | Editorial

The UK’s plans seem to outsource sovereignty for phantom efficiency. Public services provide the data and power while US tech giants reap the rewardsThere was a time when Britain aspired to be a leader in technology. These days, it seems content to be a willing supplicant – handing over its data, infrastructure and public services to US tech giants in exchange for the promise of a few percentage points of efficiency gains. Worryingly, the artificial intelligence strategy of Sir Keir Starmer’s government appears long on rhetoric, short on sovereignty and built on techno-utopian assumptions. Last week Peter Kyle, the technology secretary, was promoting the use of AI-generated discharge letters in the NHS. The tech, he said, will process complex conversations between doctors and patients, slashing paperwork and streamlining services. Ministers say that by applying AI across the public sector, the government can save £45bn.But step back and a more familiar pattern emerges. As Cecilia Rikap, a researcher at University College London, told the Politics Theory Other podcast, Britain risks becoming a satellite of the US tech industry – a nation whose public infrastructure serves primarily as a testing ground and data source for American AI models hosted on US-owned cloud computing networks. She warned that the UK should not become a site of “extractivism”, in which value – whether in the form of knowledge, labour or electricity – is supplied by Britain but monetised in the US.Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here. Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

Brooklyn pols call for act of war on the feds — a pathetic new low in NYC politics

Give up the green delusions, Albany — battery sites are too risky for New York

Mamdani is a national Dem nightmare, Egypt’s anti-Christian crusade and other commentary

QUENTIN LETTS: The encounter was electric with jeopardy... It was worse than watching a chess match when the pieces are live grenades

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: From immigration and free speech to blasphemy laws... soon we won't have a country any more. So, why do Americans care more about Britain than Labour?

Joe Biden threw open the border to rig the census — and elections for Democrats

Parents’ duties AND rights — the great divide facing New Jersey voters

Will my wife's inheritance affect our pension credit? STEVE WEBB replies

PETER VAN ONSELEN: The list of changes that could actually happen out of Jim Chalmers' economic talkfest... and the glaring omission that tells you everything you need to know

Charter schools offer hope AND deliver excellence in NYC’s toughest neighborhoods

Mayor Eric Adams deserves credit for his stunning housing wins

Donald Trump deserves praise for having the nerve to meet Vladimir Putin face-to-face

ALEX BRUMMER: Buyout grocers crushed by debt anvil

The beauty world can't stop talking about body care, so here are all the best products I've tried from the neck down: POLISHED with Elise Wilson

Even liberal Maureen Dowd of The Times admits DC is crime-ridden

Russiagate prosecutions a must, DSA ties should disqualify and other commentary

DEAR JANE: My vacation was ruined by a sneaky photo from a friend... I wasn't supposed to see THAT!

Maximum pressure on Putin is the only way to win a fair deal in Ukraine

Trump is right about border and criminals, but he’s losing voters with mass deportations

Who’s REALLY ‘destroying democracy’ — after failing to win voters legitimately?

The rizz kid: How a campus Communist turned conservative kingmaker put the ‘social’ in ‘social movement’

NY Dems aim to de-mask ICE agents to scare them off their raids — NOT to protect the public

DC Dems safety delusions: Letters to the Editor — Aug. 18, 2025

The return-to-office trend is real — and it’s spectacular for NYC

‘Real feel’ temps are a real joke — don’t trust sensational heat-index claims

Letters to the Editor: The U.S. can't solve climate crisis alone, but that's no reason to do nothing

KEVIN O'LEARY: I've spotted a crushing indicator for the US housing market... take my advice if you want to survive the financial fallout

Blame Canada: How Trump can help us from being smoked out of our summer

Carriage horse woes and more: Letters to the Editor — Aug. 17, 2025

SARAH VINE: My grandfather bore the scars of war with Japan. I wish I'd listened to him more wisely

ALEXANDRA SHULMAN'S NOTEBOOK: Should I step in when the child in a nearby house won't stop crying?

FLOURISHING AFTER 50: My husband and I split up last year. I'm now broke and too ashamed to ask for help

TONY HETHERINGTON: I warned whisky firm would cause a hangover

Contributor: It's time to save the whales again

JB Pritzker’s school-screening law mandates more mental illness — and your state could be next, parents

Insane energy policies are set to burn Democrats in New Jersey, New York

Keep racial lunacy out of air traffic control before more planes crash

Why 'Albo the activist' has more in common with Liberal hero John Howard than he'd care to admit - and what it says about the future of Australia: PVO

I'm a middle-class woman slipping into sex addiction. After an 'unforgivable' act at my best friend's birthday, I've been kicked out the group chat: ASK JANA

DAN HODGES: Palestine Action IS a terror group. But its liberal, middle-class backers think it's their right to defy the law

Put pressure on Putin, Mr. President — it’s the only way to end this war

Trump’s inspired Kennedy Center Honors picks spotlight liberals’ own performance art

Staying Juvenile: ‘Raise the Age’ is killing New York kids

Letters to the Editor: Finally, the Democrats are done with being pushed around

BORIS JOHNSON: It's the most vomit-inducing episode in all the tawdry history of international diplomacy but it will have taught Trump this vital lesson…

What to do about a crusty white tongue: DR ELLIE reveals what it means about your health, how to get rid of it... and when you should be concerned about cancer

I love my dad so much I can't bear to think he'll die one day. I'm grieving him while he's still alive. I want to hug you, writes BEL MOONEY... here's the frank truth

Alaska meeting was a start, but Putin is still up to his old tricks — and Trump knows it

'She was so f***ed up': Carolyn Bessette's friends tell MAUREEN CALLAHAN of her secret Daddy issue, JFK Jr's murder brag that drove her mad... and why everything we know about her is a lie

Sad truth about ageing men... every woman whispers about it. So many women put up with these ludicrous husbands: AMANDA PLATELL

British viewers are not sufficiently 'classy' to enjoy Meghan's Netflix series and are 'too cynical' unlike Americans: Incendiary claim of Harry's friend revealed by RICHARD EDEN... and he doesn't stop there!

ANDREW NEIL: The world is being remade. And as the Alaska talks show all too clearly, Britain and Europe are now condemned to the status of mere observers

Brooklyn Democratic Party hacks’ support of Zohran Mamdani is really about the next council Speaker and patronage

What we make of the Trump-Putin meeting: Vlad’s not ready for peace — but our prez still sees hope of getting there

Want to fix the nation’s broken higher-ed system? Look to the South

Gloucester Township’s parental accountability law: Letters to the Editor — Aug. 16, 2025

Even the most devoted ‘Sex and the City’ fans were disgusted and disappointed by ‘And Just Like That’ — the Fyre Festival of TV shows

ANDREW PIERCE: Was Afzal Khan's visit to Cyprus a bid to save his seat as he faces battle against Corbyn's new party?

ROBERT HARDMAN: Queen Camilla's tears as VJ Day hero salutes King Charles

Stop anti-Trump judges, it’s still the economy, stupid and other commentary