The Guardian view on Rachel Reeves’s speech: gambling on a mirage of stability | Editorial

The chancellor’s bid to appear fiscally credible hides a deeper weakness: a growth model built on private debt and political theatre, not real economic renewalRachel Reeves’s speech was a pre-emptive confession that Labour would almost certainly break its manifesto commitment not to put up income tax in November’s budget. The credibility gap between Labour’s political theatre and the fiscal arithmetic has been obvious for weeks. The economic fundamentals haven’t changed for the chancellor, only the politics have – notably with Reform UK and the Tories making austerity policies central to their pitch.Ms Reeves wants the coming argument to be that Labour is committed to protecting public services and jobs, while portraying her rightwing opponents as ideologically committed to shrinking the state. This is not a bad idea – if the wealthy fund it. And if a promise has to be broken, she has picked the politically optimal one – as even her shadow, Mel Stride, has conceded.Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here. Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

Trump’s Supreme Court tariff case tests the limits of presidential power

Newyork Post

Campus influencers are in tears over having fewer followers than their peers — and the grift is ruining their college experience

about 11 hours ago

New York City’s mayoral election: Letters to the Editor — Nov. 4, 2025

Newyork Post

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Panorama: Trump And The Tech Titans on BBC1: Super-villains? No, the President's tech titans are just self-obsessed geeks

about 22 hours ago

Sending Tomahawks to Kyiv won’t ignite World War III — they’ll ignite peace talks

Newyork Post

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: Starmer is a dead man walking.... and Britain's sinking rapidly into a bankrupt socialist quagmire. But there's worse loitering in the wings

1 day ago

Newyork Post

Newsom’s obscene $250M redistricting proves the urgent need for The California Post

1 day ago

Dailymail

Opinion: Real reason Reeves has not been sacked for breaking the law

1 day ago

Dailymail

The pill that's doing NOTHING for your arthritis. So many of my patients are told to take it, says DR SCURR. But these are the facts

1 day ago

New Statesman

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Game of Wool: Britain's Best Knitter: Stylish Tom Daley is the perfect host for the Great British Knit Off

2 days ago

Dailymail

I won't ever forget what I saw at Andy Cohen's party. He may admit he's hooking up with guys on every dating app… but this is the truth about men like him: KENNEDY

2 days ago

Former Prince Andrew’s biographer on how the ex-royal fell from grace

Newyork Post

Is your makeup secretly ageing you? The number one mistake you're making - and it's NOT your products: POLISHED with Elise Wilson

2 days ago

National populists surge around the world — spelling doom for the global elite

Newyork Post

SIR CLIVE WOODWARD: Why I now believe England CAN beat the All Blacks - as long as Steve Borthwick immediately fixes this one crucial flaw

3 days ago

Michael Goodwin: A Zohran Mamdani mayoralty would mean a long, sour decline for NYC

Newyork Post

ALEXANDRA SHULMAN: At 67, tax-grabbing Labour is going to force me and my son out of our home of 20 years - and I won't be the only one

3 days ago

Dailymail

DAN HODGES: REVEALED: The 7 key principles Starmer's government broke last week

3 days ago

Newyork Post

Raise the Age legislation’s dismal failure: Letters to the Editor — Nov. 2, 2025

3 days ago

Comments

Opinions

Trump’s Supreme Court tariff case tests the limits of presidential power

Letters to the Editor: Zone Zero regulations are too simplistic to solve a 'seriously complex problem'

Contributor: Voters want both 'tough on crime' and compassionate reform

Campus influencers are in tears over having fewer followers than their peers — and the grift is ruining their college experience

New York City’s mayoral election: Letters to the Editor — Nov. 4, 2025

Democrats’ big shutdown ‘win’ is only going to be setting a new record for ‘longest’ — and most futile

Tucker Carlson aims to poison us with hatred — but Donald Trump stands in the way

Family violence needs cop response, get feds out of food programs and other commentary

The sane right draws the line on Tucker Carlson and Nick Fuentes’ bile

Conspiracy kook Tucker Carlson is no patriot, no conservative and no friend to Charlie Kirk and JD Vance

Iraqi PM: Let us join in America’s peaceful prosperity — and help calm the Middle East

Women’s soccer is in a uproar over one of their own supporting, of all things, women — and they need to get a grip

Let’s get real — a vote for Sliwa is a vote to make Mamdani mayor

My pal Donald Trump is the world’s busiest man — but he still can find some time for a chat

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Panorama: Trump And The Tech Titans on BBC1: Super-villains? No, the President's tech titans are just self-obsessed geeks

Sending Tomahawks to Kyiv won’t ignite World War III — they’ll ignite peace talks

Zohran Mamdani’s ‘free buses’ are a dangerous mistake — we’ve seen how they fail

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: BBC bosses 'secretly line up Holly Willoughby for Strictly job'

QUENTIN LETTS: MPs used to treat Whitehall's panjandrums with awe. Now they snort at them with open ridicule

Contributor: The sinister message behind Trump telling pregnant women to 'tough it out'

NADINE DORRIES: My warning to William... and the bitter royal bombshells that are on the way

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: Starmer is a dead man walking.... and Britain's sinking rapidly into a bankrupt socialist quagmire. But there's worse loitering in the wings

Newsom’s obscene $250M redistricting proves the urgent need for The California Post

Opinion: Real reason Reeves has not been sacked for breaking the law

The pill that's doing NOTHING for your arthritis. So many of my patients are told to take it, says DR SCURR. But these are the facts

Britain’s fiscal reality check

My would-be assassins’ sentencing is a verdict for liberty and a warning to dictators

Nonhostile takeover: How the Democratic Party gave in to radicals like Mamdani

It’ll be EASY for a Mayor Mamdani to abandon the schools

Democrats are losing pride in America — and that’s a problem for BOTH

John Brennan’s unhinged blowup over ‘Dirty 51’ letter, Hunter Biden laptop shows he’s worried

Bill Gates finally got to right answer on climate change — but not before immense harm

STEPHEN GLOVER: Is this the REAL reason Rachel Reeves has not been sacked for breaking the law?

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Game of Wool: Britain's Best Knitter: Stylish Tom Daley is the perfect host for the Great British Knit Off

I won't ever forget what I saw at Andy Cohen's party. He may admit he's hooking up with guys on every dating app… but this is the truth about men like him: KENNEDY

Former Prince Andrew’s biographer on how the ex-royal fell from grace

Is mega-phony Gavin Newsom the best the Democrats can do?

RUTH SUNDERLAND: The alarming curse of AI workslop is upon us

Pervasive social-emotional learning brings Big Brother to the classroom

ANDREW PIERCE: Did Tony Blair help sweeten Andrew's Royal Lodge deal?

Gavin Newsom has high hopes — but rock-bottom results

City-run grocery stores are losers, Antifa is all too real and other commentary

Is your makeup secretly ageing you? The number one mistake you're making - and it's NOT your products: POLISHED with Elise Wilson

National populists surge around the world — spelling doom for the global elite

DR ELLIE CANNON: The 4 things you MUST do to help combat kidney disease

Trump has already put Biden’s record to shame after just 9 months

Zohran Mamdani’s City Hall will see ideology crash against reality

Andrew Cuomo’s final stretch: Letters to the Editor — Nov. 3, 2025

Opinion: Starmer will do everything he can to save this terrible Chancellor

Abcarian: Proposed settlement between feds and UCLA is a master class in extortion

I can't disclose my medical history to my partner. If I do... he'll find me so unsexy that he'll leave: DEAR JANE

SARAH VINE: This is what the future now holds for Andrew Mountbatten Windsor

SIR CLIVE WOODWARD: Why I now believe England CAN beat the All Blacks - as long as Steve Borthwick immediately fixes this one crucial flaw

Michael Goodwin: A Zohran Mamdani mayoralty would mean a long, sour decline for NYC

MAIL ON SUNDAY COMMENT: How on earth can we believe a single word from this Chancellor?

FLOURISHING AFTER 50: We gave our daughter $100,000 to buy a home - and now her ex-husband is living in it

PETER HITCHENS: What Charles' humiliation of Andrew REALLY means for the future of the monarchy - and our country

ALEXANDRA SHULMAN: At 67, tax-grabbing Labour is going to force me and my son out of our home of 20 years - and I won't be the only one

DAN HODGES: REVEALED: The 7 key principles Starmer's government broke last week

Raise the Age legislation’s dismal failure: Letters to the Editor — Nov. 2, 2025