The Guardian view on Scottish politics: Labour wins the seat but not – yet – the argument | Editorial

A Tory collapse, the SNP’s slump and Reform’s rise signal a volatile shift – and the return to deal-making after the next Holyrood electionLabour’s victory in the Holyrood byelection offers the UK government a rare political comfort but not, perhaps, the strategic breakthrough it might like to imagine. A late flurry of welfare signalling, a dogged ground campaign and a carefully staged visit to a Govan shipyard by Sir Keir Starmer helped shore up Labour’s appeal to its traditional voters in Scotland’s industrial belt. Yet as Prof John Curtice has noted, Labour’s share of the vote actually declined compared with the last time voters cast ballots here in 2021 – a year in which the party was placed a distant third and was polling at the same dismal level of public support, 20%, it has today.The prime minister will gladly pocket Davy Russell’s win in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse. But it is a foothold. There is still a steep climb to the summit. More telling is who lost. The Scottish National party’s poor showing reflects dissatisfaction with its record of governance and the diminishing appeal of independence in areas where Labour has deep roots. The real surprise was Reform UK, taking over a quarter of the vote and leapfrogging the Conservatives into third place. It drew from both main parties, fuelled by protest and unionist anger that flattened the Tories. Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

Newyork Post

Prez-pardon problems go far beyond Joe Biden’s fishy signatures

about 1 hour ago

Dailymail

DAILY MAIL COMMENT: Why the death of the Tory Party has been greatly exaggerated

about 1 hour ago

Dailymail

Daniel Levy's ridiculous decision to sack Ange Postecoglou is Tottenham's loss, writes CHRIS SUTTON - he will go and win silverware elsewhere

about 1 hour ago

Don’t let the Trump-Musk breakup harm ‘kids’ NASA and SpaceX

Newyork Post

EPHRAIM HARDCASTLE: What made Jane Seymour perfect for her 'virginal' James Bond role? And what did King Charles ask royal finance chief to investigate about Andrew?

about 18 hours ago

The Pride month vibes are off, but there's still hope.

NPR

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: Children are being killed because we are too scared of being called racist. When will this dangerous madness end?

1 day ago

Dailymail

TOM UTLEY: Mrs U has a self-imposed hosepipe ban. But I don't know why she bothers when Thames Water wastes more than half a BILLION litres every day

1 day ago

Dailymail

JAN MOIR: Meghan's bizarre twerking in the delivery room is just the latest desperate bid for publicity from the Sussexes. Whatever happened to their pleas for privacy?

1 day ago

Dailymail

Billionaire oligarch's lover is thrown out of her home with her kids while a sports presenter hits back at 'horrific' criticism about her weight: RICHARD EDEN'S DIARY

1 day ago

Dailymail

ANDREW PIERCE: Reform's precocious political ingenue will be back, but there is deep trouble at the heart of Farage's party

1 day ago

A top MAGA defector has told me the REAL revenge Elon's plotting... it could destroy Trump's legacy: KENNEDY

Dailymail

The week in whoppers: Hakeem Jeffries flips inflation on its head, Chuck Schumer scaremongers on the GOP’s budget bill and more

1 day ago

Democrats pledge to help people break the law, no matter the cost

Newyork Post

Comments

Opinions

Prez-pardon problems go far beyond Joe Biden’s fishy signatures

DAILY MAIL COMMENT: Why the death of the Tory Party has been greatly exaggerated

Daniel Levy's ridiculous decision to sack Ange Postecoglou is Tottenham's loss, writes CHRIS SUTTON - he will go and win silverware elsewhere

Don’t let the Trump-Musk breakup harm ‘kids’ NASA and SpaceX

The Chinese fungus-smuggling couple: Letters to the Editor — June 7, 2025

Letters to the Editor: Amid tree house standoff, 'what options do the unhoused have left?'

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: Cancelled 'Dreaded Meghan' professor returns to arts role

Why Pres. Trump will win his battle against elite higher education

AI requires an explosion in power, both parties are losing ground and other commentary

ALEX BRUMMER: 'Wise old hen' Chancellor dances on a pinhead

Beware: The Human Rights Campaign is just a scam to push lefty issues

Keir Starmer is about as frightening as a stick of celery… but I’m more scared of him than Putin – here’s why

£4million a DAY migrant hotel bill will continue to spiral unless Labour does three things

Letter to the editor: Hey, those were my tax credits

Senate Judiciary Committee declassifies FBI's files outlining plot to undermine Trump

Our Operation Spider Web drone attack proves no one should count Ukraine out

How NYC is stepping up to stop attacks on Jews BEFORE they happen

How Scottish Labour’s ground war delivered victory in key by-election

Letter to the editor: Stop giving Iran more time

Letter to the editor: Five reasons U.S. should reengage with NATO

It’s not a shot that’s been fired across the SNP’s bows, it’s a cruise missile

Letters to the Editor: After Tom Girardi scandal, it's clear the State Bar of California needs reform

Jeremy Hunt: A Conservative-Reform coalition is “not going to happen”

It's time to stop the scaremongering over heat pumps

A vital debate for tertiary education sector

This is a set-back and an opportunity for the SNP - which one will they embrace?

EPHRAIM HARDCASTLE: What made Jane Seymour perfect for her 'virginal' James Bond role? And what did King Charles ask royal finance chief to investigate about Andrew?

The Pride month vibes are off, but there's still hope.

It's quaint the things you find in some people's bathrooms...

Best get used to it: Reform and indy will be at the heart of our debate for years

Edinburgh's West Town: A new city rising – or a chance slipping away?

I know frustration of commuting from Edinburgh's suburbs by bus. Here's my solution

Please tell us, Mr Swinney: how exactly would you defend Scotland?

HBO and the cursed child

Island of strangers? So who should we listen to on immigration?

Gun rights under fire

Ryan Routh, duct tape assassin

The Chinese spies among us

Trump and Rumble are at the center of the global battle for free expression

South Korea's tumult and what's at stake for America

We live in the land of the free because of the brave

Senate must advance SAVE Act

Christian baker's plight highlights California's disregard for First Amendment

Lefties furious at the ‘indignity’ of deporting illegal migrants should really blame the guy who let them all in

QUENTIN LETTS: So noble was the minister's school-meal pulpiteering, you'd think it was the abolition of slavery

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: Children are being killed because we are too scared of being called racist. When will this dangerous madness end?

TOM UTLEY: Mrs U has a self-imposed hosepipe ban. But I don't know why she bothers when Thames Water wastes more than half a BILLION litres every day

JAN MOIR: Meghan's bizarre twerking in the delivery room is just the latest desperate bid for publicity from the Sussexes. Whatever happened to their pleas for privacy?

Billionaire oligarch's lover is thrown out of her home with her kids while a sports presenter hits back at 'horrific' criticism about her weight: RICHARD EDEN'S DIARY

ANDREW PIERCE: Reform's precocious political ingenue will be back, but there is deep trouble at the heart of Farage's party

A top MAGA defector has told me the REAL revenge Elon's plotting... it could destroy Trump's legacy: KENNEDY

New York City’s needed e-bike crackdown: Letters to the Editor — June 6, 2025

Fresh grounds to snap back Iran sanctions — and block it from getting a nuclear bomb

Ignore the hysteria over GOP ‘cuts’ to Medicaid — it would still GROW dangerously fast

The week in whoppers: Hakeem Jeffries flips inflation on its head, Chuck Schumer scaremongers on the GOP’s budget bill and more

Democrats pledge to help people break the law, no matter the cost

Trans influencer filming in the women’s room at Disney World is everything that’s wrong with this selfish movement

Zohran Mamdani’s anti-Israel stance disqualifies him AND anyone who supports him

Douglas Murray: Liberals turn killers, racists, and haters into martyrs

SCOTUS’ unanimous discrimination call is a huge win for equality