Whatever the truth of The Salt Path, I know why people wanted to believe it | Gaby Hinsliff

As questions are asked about the bestselling memoir, is the demand for hope-over-hardship stories outstripping reality?Was the story always, in hindsight, just a little too good to be true? A middle-aged couple, brutally down on their luck after bankruptcy and a terminal diagnosis, escape their troubles on an epic walk round the South West Coast Path, finding comfort along the way in the kindness of strangers. Billed as an “honest and life-affirming” story of prevailing against the odds, The Salt Path became first a bestseller and then a blockbuster film, starring a windswept Gillian Anderson. Though it was never really my thing, I knew plenty of people for whom The Salt Path genuinely resonated, with its romantic central theme of being (as the film’s director, Marianne Elliott, put it) “reformed by the elements” of a blustery English seascape.If it seemed a bit unlikely that a dying man could be rejuvenated by a strenuous trek involving wild camping in all weathers – well, getting readers to suspend their disbelief is what good storytellers do, and The Salt Path’s Raynor Winn was definitely good. Arguably, as I said, too good.Gaby Hinsliff is a Guardian columnistDo you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here. Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

Sicko liberals celebrating the death of little girls in Texas floods tells you everything about the new evil rot infecting America: MAUREEN CALLAHAN

SARAH VINE: This is Labour's disturbing plan on immigration... and why Starmer's red-carpet summit with the mocking Macron is a farce

Malicious critics are scrambling to blame Trump for the deadly Texas floods

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Heatwaves: The New Normal? It used to be called 'summer', now a hot spell has the BBC in meltdown

NADINE DORRIES: Lucy Letby wants to see me. I filled in the paperwork six months ago. So who's blocking my prison visit - and why?

This is the troubling comment Kelly Osbourne made to me - and why she now faces a serious marriage dilemma after accepting her Slipknot boyfriend's proposal: RICHARD EDEN'S DIARY

Take a political time-out, Elon Musk: ‘America Party’ rant proves even your genius has its limits

Lefty responses to the Texas flooding horror are demented and depraved

Kathy Hochul’s highway-robbery bragging puts Willie Sutton to shame

Log off, Elon, and drop the ‘America Party’ plan

QUENTIN LETTS: The yelps of Tory mirth could have been the canned laughter they used on The Flintstones

Republicans’ righteous win on the ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ saved the party’s future

Albany will slice a lifeline for New York’s abused kids — unless Kathy Hochul takes a stand

Trump’s Big Beautiful Bill signing: Letters to the Editor — July 8, 2025

Eddie Jordan's send-off was a reminder that life in sport is so noble that it's harrowing when it's taken away, writes OLIVER HOLT

Zohran just played colleges’ race game, Dems’ anti-city ‘paucity’ agenda and other commentary

'Vindictive mum who sparked teen Marcus Fakana's Dubai jail hell should apologise'

Reboot for equity culture: Only British-focused funds should qualify for tax relief, says ALEX BRUMMER

Zohran Mamdani’s ‘radical ingratitude’ to the city and nation that gave him everything

If the mum whose complaint sparked Marcus Fakana's jail hell has anything shame left, she'd apologise to his parents - and hope they'd accept it

How do personal pension contributions affect what Universal Credit I receive? STEVE WEBB replies

Unless we live within our means, Reeves' teardrops will become a torrent - for her and the British people: STEPHEN GLOVER

Zohran Mamdani’s other baggage — bringing a socialist army to City Hall

Pathetic Democrats are falling over themselves and in line with the dangerous Zohran Mamdani

Slow learner... Kendall forgets her own history: ANDREW PIERCE

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews last night's TV: Inspirational Live Aid still brings a lump to the throat after 40 years

I've discovered the secrets to banishing those unsightly 'tech neck' lines and wrinkles... and they start from $10: POLISHED with Elise Wilson

ALEX BRUMMER: The folly of Labour wealth taxes

Democrats still clueless, Mamdani’s insulting child care ‘fix’ and other commentary

Why England's bowlers weren't happy with the Edgbaston pitch and there are many better options than Shoaib Bashir: BUMBLE ON THE TEST

NASSER HUSSAIN: Ben Stokes' bowling attack were dead on their feet in the second Test... the Indians got so much more out of the Edgbaston pitch

Unlike Zohran Mamdani, most Dems want prosperity — not class warfare

KENNEDY: The most vile celebrities I've ever met, including an A-list actor who called me a m*****f*****. These narcissists can't get away with it... I'm naming names

Trump’s ‘Alligator Alcatraz’ migrant center: Letters to the Editor — July 7, 2025

To tame Washington, we need a DOGE 2.0 — but done right this time

On Day 1, DA Alvin Bragg put criminals first — I’ll end his era of excuses

Letters to the Editor: LACMA's transformation deserves more credit than the L.A. Times is giving it

Trump can’t give up the fight against foreign meddling in US tech

The putrid Kohberger plea deal and more: Letters to the Editor — July 6, 2025

Contributor: The overhaul of L.A. County government begins now

Op-Comic: In troubling times, we turn to the global comfort food

Contributor: L.A. has more to do to fight antisemitism and protect Jewish residents

Contributor: When an unnatural heat wave kills, has Big Oil committed murder?

Contributor: In precarious times, an old restaurant idea makes new sense

Contributor: Why public lands should stay public and protected

Contributor: Op-Comic: SCOTUS' demolition

KENNEDY: The most vile celebrities I've ever met, including an A-list actor who called me a mf. These narcissists can't get away with it... I'm naming names