"Abundance" movement sparks Dems' identity fight for 2028

The fight over the future direction of the Democratic Party has begun.The first battlefield is the trendy center-left "Abundance" movement. A growing number of left-wing politicians and thinkers are labeling it a clever rebrand by the party's corporate wing, which they blame for driving working-class voters from the party.Why it matters: The escalating feud is a preview of the 2028 presidential primary, as the Democratic Party grapples with its identity — including whether to moderate to attract independent voters, or counter Trumpism by leaning into progressive economic populism.State of play: "Abundance" was popularized by this year's bestselling book of the same name by New York Times columnist Ezra Klein and journalist Derek Thompson.The idea: Democrats have lost voters' trust because of governing failures in blue cities and states, and need to respond by cutting excess regulations to build more housing, energy projects and more."Liberals speak as if they believe in government — and then pass policy after policy hamstringing what it can actually do," the authors wrote.As Democrats continue to reckon with how Donald Trump returned to the White House and the ongoing fallout from the 2024 elections, many in the party are enthusiastically embracing Abundance.California Gov. Gavin Newsom, a potential 2028 presidential candidate, signed legislation in June to change environmental rules to make it easier to build more housing. He posted on X that "we're urgently embracing an abundance agenda by tearing down the barriers that have delayed new affordable housing and infrastructure for decades."Tech billionaire and prolific Democratic donor Reid Hoffman said in late July that he's sending everyone he knows a copy of the book, and that he'll be backing pro-abundance candidates.Open Philanthropy, a deep-pocketed funder with roots in Silicon Valley and liberal-minded politics, announced in March it would back the movement by spending $120 million in the next three years through an "Abundance and Growth Fund."Between the lines: The abundance buzz hasn't been universally accepted — and has drawn some backlash from the Democratic Party's left wing. Those Democrats argue:Getting rid of excessive regulations is good, but doesn't address — and in some ways could exacerbate — the more pressing issues of wealth inequality and corporate power.Voters are angry, and a deregulation agenda isn't a compelling political message.What they're saying: Progressive Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) told CNN on Sunday that removing some regulations would be good, but "that is not the fundamental problem facing America," pointing instead to income inequality and the billionaire class."Much of what abundance supporters are saying is fine: Yes, there's red tape that doesn't make sense, and let's get rid of it," Dan Geldon, a former senior adviser to Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), told Axios."But abundance supporters generally ignore red tape that's there because of corporations protecting their own interests. As a whole, it's really just recycled incrementalism and a call to make the party less ambitious and milquetoast, despite the scale of the economic problems voters care about."Mike Konczal, a former member of then-President Biden's National Economic Council, said: "Fixing government procurement is not exciting people. It's a burn-it-all-down electorate and Democrats need to offer people more."The other side: Klein has been taken aback by the intensity of some of the criticism, and believes that populists who want to enact ambitious government programs need to show voters they're capable of implementing such programs."I expect there will be a number of politicians in 2028 that are running on abundance, populist and anti-oligarchal themes," Klein told Axios. "The idea that someone is going to just pick one of these things is stupid — talented politicians aren't just one thing."Alexander Berger, the CEO of Open Philanthropy, said in a statement the group is proud of its funding efforts: "The first step to solving a problem is recognizing it's real. Blindness to the regulatory constraints that choke off growth directly limits access to affordable housing, energy, and health care."Some progressives and Thompson, the book's co-author, argue that most of the backlash to the abundance movement is from hyper-online people trying to pick fights."I've seen a bit of a poster-politician divide in the response," Thompson, who recently launched his own Substack, told Axios. "If you limit your exposure to abundance criticism online, it's not hard to find objections on the left."He noted that some Democrats already have embraced the ideas he and Klein proposed.

Comments

World news

Russian foreign minister wears USSR jumper as he arrives at Trump-Putin summit in Alaska

Independent

Teenager who murdered British mother in her Australian home has sentence REDUCED - as family say they are 'broken' by the decision

about 2 hours ago

Sergei Lavrov trolls the West by wearing Soviet CCCP top to showdown between Trump and Putin in Alaska

Dailymail

Shock cancer twist for family of glamorous bikini designer found dead on New York yacht after Irish family called for second post-mortem

about 4 hours ago

Dailymail

Putin comes to America: Russian leader heads to Pacific Coast in heavily armoured limo before jetting to Alaska for historic meeting with Trump

about 4 hours ago

Dailymail

First photos 'of Putin's youngest son, six-year-old Vladimir Junior' are revealed - as it's claimed his private tutors earn $36,000 a month

about 4 hours ago

Dailymail

Horrifying moment father is snatched by crocodile and dragged to his doom in front of his family as they bathe in river… before bystanders bravely battle the beast to recover the victim's body

about 4 hours ago

'Fully in support': Some Alberta separatists try to rally support in the Trump White House

National Post

Comments

World news

Russian foreign minister wears USSR jumper as he arrives at Trump-Putin summit in Alaska

Louisiana AG calls Roblox ‘perfect place for pedophiles’ in lawsuit amid calls for CEO’s resignation

DC police will share information on anyone officers encounter with ICE agents

Marjorie Taylor Greene says Zelensky ‘doesn’t want peace’ ahead of Trump-Putin summit

‘Extremely worrying’ situation in Spain as 14 major wildfires rage

Russian rouble value dips ahead of Trump-Putin meeting

Trump has privately pondered if Epstein accusers are just ‘Democrats’ trying to make him look bad, report claims

Home Depots across L.A. become battleground in new phase of ICE raids

Inside the border command center tracking migrants with drones

Everything we know about Trump and Putin’s Alaska summit today

Robert Jenrick’s Calais visit is a stunt – and a good one at that

11 low-effort ways to have the best BBQ ever – from a food editor

Trump-Putin meeting: Understand the aims, stakes, and what could happen next

After losing eight stone, people treat me much better in dating

Inside Sunderland’s survival plan with two more transfers targeted

The fake news that helped put us on a path to Mars

The Nvidia chip deal that has Trump officials threatening to quit

Why inflation is making stock market investors bullish

Scoop: White House hands down loyalty ratings for hundreds of companies

India 'will not tolerate' nuclear blackmail, says Modi in warning to Pakistan

Heavy rains expected in Puerto Rico and Virgin Islands as Tropical Storm Erin nears

Hezbollah vows to keep arms, says Lebanon's disarmament plan serves Israel

N.S. missing kids: Signs about Lilly and Jack Sullivan pop up as case remains unsolved

Man accused of killing, dismembering 2 people in Huntsville, Ont.

Best Ninja products to buy for all your 2025 summer festivities

Out-of-control jet ski nearly mows down beachgoers relaxing on Costa del Sol

Judge shot dead, stabbed and has genitals stuffed in mouth after being accused of affair

Explosion at Russian weapons plant kills five ahead of Trump-Putin summit

Brother cut off his dead sibling's ear and stored it in freezer in disturbing DNA row

Teenager who murdered British mother in her Australian home has sentence REDUCED - as family say they are 'broken' by the decision

Sergei Lavrov trolls the West by wearing Soviet CCCP top to showdown between Trump and Putin in Alaska

What to expect from historic Trump-Putin Alaska summit over Ukraine-Russia ceasefire

Prayers for peace in Alaska ahead of Trump-Putin summit

A mechanic lost his wallet while working – a decade later it turned up 151,000 miles away

Conservative TV host crashes Jasmine Crockett town hall to call Democrat a ‘fake ghetto hoodrat’

Australian teenager who fatally stabbed British woman wins appeal to reduce sentence

How Team Trump’s terrifying weaknesses play into Putin’s hands at the Alaska summit

Lawyer issues apology after using AI-generated fake quotes in murder case

Putin praises ‘heroic’ North Korean troops fighting in Ukraine in letter to Kim Jong-un

The latest on Man City’s 115 charges – and ‘nuclear’ punishment they could face

New bat tunnel controversy and millions on unused trains: the East West rail fiasco

My son married a boring woman – I’m worried their kids will be dull too

Australian lawyer apologizes for AI-generated errors in murder case

On India's Independence Day, Modi vows to punish Pakistan for future attacks

Turkish authorities detain Istanbul district mayor in sweeping crackdown on opposition

Serbian protesters are back on the streets as clashes with government loyalists escalate

Killer of British mother in Australia eligible for earlier release after appeal

The economic party rolls on for the rich. For everyone else, not so much

Some blue cities in red states have the nation's highest homicide rates, FBI number show

Putin visits U.S. for Trump summit as a peer, not a pariah