AI's race in the dark with China

The U.S.'s great AI race with China, now freshly embraced by President Trump, is a competition in the dark with no clear prize or finish line.Why it matters: Similar "races" of the past — like the nuclear arms race and the space race — have sparked innovation, but victories haven't lasted long or meant much.The big picture: Both Silicon Valley and the U.S. government now agree that we must invest untold billions to build supporting infrastructure for an error-prone, energy-hungry technology with an unproven business model and an unpredictable impact on the economy and jobs.What they're saying: "America is the country that started the AI race. And as president of the United States, I'm here today to declare that America is going to win it," Trump said at a Wednesday event titled "Winning the AI Race."Policy experts and industry leaders who promote the "race" idea argue that the U.S. and China are in a head-to-head competition to win the future of AI by achieving research breakthroughs, establishing the technology's standards and breaking the AGI or "superintelligence" barrier.They suggest that the world faces a binary choice between free, U.S.-developed AI imbued with democratic values or a Chinese alternative that's under the thumb of the Communist Party.Flashback: The last time a scientific race had truly world-shaping consequences was during the Second World War, as the Manhattan Project beat the Nazis to the atomic bomb.But Germany surrendered well before the U.S. had revealed or made use of its discovery.The nuclear arms race with the Soviet Union that followed was a decades-long stalemate that cost fortunes and more than once left the planet teetering on an apocalyptic brink.The 1960s space race was similarly inconclusive.Russia got humanity into space ahead of the U.S., but the U.S. made it to the moon first.Once that leg of the race was over, both countries retreated from further human exploration of space for decades.State of play: With AI, U.S. leaders are once again saying the race is on — but this time the scorecard is even murkier."Build a bomb before Hitler" or "Put a man on the moon" are comprehensible objectives, but no one is providing similar clarity for the AI competition.The best the industry can say is that we are racing toward AI that's smarter than people. But no two companies or experts have the same definition of "smart" — for humans or AI models.We can't even say with confidence which of any two AI models is "smarter" right now, because we lack good measures and we don't always know or agree on what we want the technology to do.Between the lines: The "beat China" drumbeat is coming largely from inside the industry, which now has a direct line to the White House via Trump's AI adviser, David Sacks."Whoever ends up winning ends up building the AI rails for the world," OpenAI chief global affairs officer Chris Lehane said at an Axios event in March.Arguing for controls on U.S. chip exports to China earlier this year, Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei described competitor DeepSeek as "beholden to an authoritarian government that has committed human rights violations, has behaved aggressively on the world stage, and will be far more unfettered in these actions if they're able to match the U.S. in AI."Yes, but: In the era of the second Trump administration, many Americans view their own government as increasingly authoritarian.With Trump himself getting into the business of dictating the political slant of AI products, it's harder for America's champions to sell U.S. alternatives as more "free."China has been catching up to the U.S. in AI research and development, most tech experts agree. They see the U.S. maintaining a shrinking lead of at most a couple of years and perhaps as little as months.But this edge is largely meaningless, since innovations propagate broadly and quickly in the AI industry.And cultural and language differences mean that the U.S. and its allies will never just switch over to Chinese suppliers even if their AI outruns the U.S. competition.In this, AI is more like social media than like steel, solar panels or other fungible goods.The bottom line: The U.S. and China are both going to have increasingly advanced AI in coming years. The race between them is more a convenient fiction that marshals money and minds than a real conflict with an outcome that matters.

Comments

World news

Suspect arrested after ‘random’ stabbing at Michigan Walmart leaves 6 critically injured, 5 others hurt

Independent

Comments

Similar News

Spanish teenager investigated on suspicion of creating AI-generated nude videos

Software group Auterion to ship 33,000 AI drone ‘strike kits’ to Ukraine

Indian film company to rerelease romantic drama with AI ‘happy ending’

DOGE plans to use AI to identify 50% of 200,000 federal regulations that can be eliminated by Trump

Doge reportedly using AI tool to create ‘delete list’ of federal regulations

China calls for global AI cooperation days after Trump administration unveils low-regulation strategy

China proposes global cooperation framework on AI

AI start-up Anthropic open to Mideast funds in talks for $150bn valuation

AI-backed medical debt company claims payment plans can help US healthcare costs

Is AI really plotting against us?

The real winners from Trump’s ‘AI action plan’? Tech companies

MTG again lashes out at Trump this time over his AI plan: ‘An absolute threat to federalism’

Trump's AI plan calls for massive data centers. Here's how it may affect energy in the U.S.

Google’s AI fight is moving to new ground

Trump slams ‘woke’ AI models

Nvidia AI chips worth $1bn smuggled to China after Trump export controls

Powering UK’s AI growth plan risks burning political capital

Fake daughter, phoney son & AI generated wife – how shameless influencers are cashing in on Andy Byron kiss cam scandal

Trump's AI plans include a time bomb for tech companies

Trump signs three executive orders targeting ‘woke’ AI models

World news

Suspect arrested after ‘random’ stabbing at Michigan Walmart leaves 6 critically injured, 5 others hurt

Thomas Massie says Epstein files need to be released ‘for the victims’ and demands a vote to release info

Wanna get away? Sorry, there’s no destination safe from seasonal allergies

Contributor: Jim Crow meets ICE at 'Alligator Alcatraz'

Commentary: Political ploy or bold move to save democracy? Our columnists debate Newsom redistricting threat

Mum of Air India crash victim ‘appalled’ after being given wrong remains

TikTok star found dead after ‘refusing marriage proposal’

Lionesses fans start the party early ahead of Euros final

The growing threat of battery fires from e-scooters and e-bikes

Trump's economy faces historic week on interest rates, trade, jobs and more

What to do when you're a Trump target: corporate edition

AI's race in the dark with China

Thailand and Cambodia agree to peace talks after Trump intervention - but shelling continues

Greece and Turkey wildfires: Killer blazes force tourists and locals to flee

Firefighters battle to contain Greek wildfires

How a flat tire scam in Colombia can lead to costly car repairs

Doctors warn that children in Gaza have suffered irreversible damage from starvation

His name is Mohammad Al-Motawaq. He is 18 months old. And he is starving in Gaza

Thai and Cambodian leaders to meet in Malaysia for talks to end deadly border dispute

Trump supporters tell president ‘Don’t trust Starmer’ as he hits the golf course for second day

Iconic TV German mouse statue damaged in arson attack

‘Apocalyptic’ Turkey wildfires spread as 14 killed in blazes sparked by record 50C heatwave

Vatican asked to defrock priest charged with killing homeless man who was set on fire

Bob Geldof issues rallying call to Israelis to protest against against Gaza starvation

Motion cameras were set up in the jungles of Guatemala — and they captured something incredible

The real reason we tip

Why Israel’s next conflict could be with Turkey

‘I live in Gaza. It’s an open mortuary – you can smell death everywhere’

Russia scales down celebrations honoring its navy as Ukraine launches more drone attacks

Iran executes 2 opposition members over alleged attacks on civilian sites

Trump gives his view on chances of US-EU trade deal - while on the golf course

Firefighters tackle blazes as 'apocalyptic' wildfires break out across southeast Europe

The most useful Amazon house hacks that will simplify your life

Inside 'German Magaluf' where 'disrespectful' holidaymakers leave locals furious

Abandoned hotel where beds made and food is still on tables

Holiday from hell as woman pinned to bed covered in vomit after falling ill

'Hell on Earth': Venezuelans deported to El Salvador mega-prison tell of brutal abuse

Israel begins a limited pause in fighting in 3 Gaza areas as concerns over hunger mount

Israel Says It Has Paused Some Military Activity in Gaza as Anger Grows Over Hunger

Kemi Badenoch clashes with Bob Geldof after Live Aid organiser accuses Israel of ‘lying’ over Gaza aid

Russia launches first direct passenger flights connecting Moscow and Pyongyang in decades

Taliban fighters 'have been brought to the UK on secret airlift flights' after Afghanistan data breach

I finally exercise four times a week – but I’d hate for anyone to see how

Like Ulrika Jonsson, I loved sunbathing – then I got skin cancer

How fuel used in ‘green’ bin lorries could be destroying rainforests

How baby formula marketing could be risking infant health – and mislead parents

Warsaw archbishop asks Vatican to defrock Polish priest charged with the killing of a homeless man

At least 21 killed as Islamic State-backed rebels attack Congo church: Civil leader

Parts of Athens evacuated after more than 50 wildfires in 24 hours

Most notorious cruise ship deaths as Netflix airs chilling Amy Bradley mystery

Cruise ship abandoned on a seasick-inducing tilt is eerily frozen in time

Madeleine McCann suspect set to be tagged to stop him vanishing when he is freed

Putin warns of nuclear war after unleashing another night of hell on Ukraine

Screams and chaos: The moments after Bangladesh fighter jet hit a primary school

Cameroon opposition leader banned from challenging world's oldest president

The Far Right in Germany Wants to Soften Its Image, Not Its Policies

Kartik Kumra Was Ready for Indian’s Fashion Moment