Bill would force ICE agents to ID themselves, ban them from wearing masks

Federal immigration agents would be banned from wearing most face coverings but be required to wear visible ID during public enforcement operations, according to a proposal from Democratic U.S. Sens. Alex Padilla (D-CA) and Cory Booker (D-NJ).Why it matters: The long-shot proposal comes following images of masked, heavily armed immigration agents snatching people off the streets and taking them away in unmarked cars have shocked many Americans.Driving the news: Under the proposed bill unveiled Tuesday, Homeland Security agents from Customs and Border Protection (CBP) and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) would be required to display a legible ID that includes the agency name or acronym.They'd also have to include information on their names or badge numbers.This requirement would extend to federal agents detailed to immigration operations, and deputized state or local officers.Zoom in: The bill also would prohibit non-medical face coverings (such as masks or balaclavas) that obscure identity or facial visibility, with exceptions for environmental hazards or covert operations.In addition, it would require the Department of Homeland Security to establish disciplinary procedures for violations, report annually to Congress, and investigate complaints through its Office for Civil Rights and Civil Liberties.Context: ICE agents are currently not required to wear body cameras, can cover their faces, don't have to provide badge numbers or identify themselves, can arrive in unmarked cars and they don't need a warrant from a judge to detain someone.ICE agents operated with vastly more enforcement power, less transparency and fewer guardrails than local police and other federal agencies since ICE was created in 2003. State of play: The Trump administration's stepped-up immigration enforcement as part of a mass deportation effort has exposed the ICE agents' tactical exceptions.Administration officials say the secrecy is necessary to prevent agent doxing and for enforcement.Critics argue that other agencies are required to identify themselves, and the lack of transparency is merely an excuse to create a secret police force.What they're saying: "When federal immigration agents show up and pull someone off the street in plainclothes with their face obscured and no visible identification, it only escalates tensions and spreads fear while shielding federal agents from basic accountability," Padilla said.Padilla said the VISIBLE Act would "restore transparency and ensure impersonators can't exploit the panic" during raids."The masked bandit is a symbol of fear, and having government agents dressed like paramilitaries is un-American," Scott Shuchart, a former ICE and DHS (Office for Civil Rights and Civil Liberties) official who supports the measure, said.The other side: Tricia McLaughlin, a Department of Homeland Security spokesperson, has defended ICE agents' tactics and the use of face coverings.She told Axios that ICE agents have faced a 700% surge in assaults against them in recent weeks.McLaughlin said DHS enforcement operations are highly targeted and blamed Democrats for "violent rhetoric" against ICE agents.Zoom out: ICE was formed in 2003. It was placed under the control of the new Department of Homeland Security and replaced the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS), which had been under the Justice Department.To protect national security after the terror attacks on Sept. 11, 2001, lawmakers gave ICE a unique combination of civil and criminal authorities.Between the lines: Officers in other agencies are required to identify themselves and provide badge numbers to prevent impersonators. ICE has no such requirement, and there have been reports of ICE impersonators harassing people, creating more chaos and uncertainty in some communities.What we're watching: The pressure to rein in some of ICE's enforcement tactics does have support among some conservatives worried about over policing.However, it's unclear whether such a proposal would garner any support from Republicans concerned about upsetting President Trump.

Comments

World news

You can finally keep your shoes on at the airport, say TSA after years of frustrating checks

Independent

Tragic picture shows entire cabin of Camp Mystic girls and counsellors swept away in Texas floods - as death toll rises to over 100

about 3 hours ago

Donald Trump says US will send more weapons to Ukraine after Putin rejects peace talks

Metro

Comments

Similar News

Jon Stewart uses GOP’s own words to skewer lawmakers who voted for Trump’s controversial bill

Trump bill gives ICE $45 billion for detaining immigrants - more than it received in the last 15 years combined

Thailand's Cabinet withdraws a controversial bill to legalize casinos

Ted Cruz ensured Trump spending bill slashed weather forecasting funding

Colleges will soon have to fork over millions of dollars as Trump’s bill extends a tax on their endowments

Welfare bill will now lift 50,000 out of poverty after U-turns, assessment finds

Planned Parenthood sues Trump administration over funding cuts in big bill

'I bought Dublin's 'best pint of Guinness' - and was floored when I saw the bill'

Trump bill's health effects won't be felt until after midterms

That Social Security email about the "big, beautiful bill," explained

The Economic Consequences of the Big Odious Bill

Convicted murderer Lori Bill Germa escapes from Archambault Institution in Quebec

Convicted murderer Lori Bill Germa, 69, escapes from a prison in Quebec

How Trump's big budget bill would jump-start his immigration agenda

So big, so beautiful: Fox News ignores the critics and champions Trump’s bill

Trump Scores Win in Passing His ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’

U.S. House Narrowly Passes Trump’s ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’

Trump’s “Big Beautiful Bill” Leaves the Congressional Budget Office Battling for Relevance

What Trump’s massive bill would actually do, explained

Does Trump really not understand his huge bill cuts Medicaid?

World news

You can finally keep your shoes on at the airport, say TSA after years of frustrating checks

Trump bill gives ICE $45 billion for detaining immigrants - more than it received in the last 15 years combined

One man gored and others bruised in Spain’s bull running festival

US children much more likely to die than in similar countries, study finds

Texas floods mapped: Here are the affected areas as death toll rises

Jon Stewart uses GOP’s own words to skewer lawmakers who voted for Trump’s controversial bill

Scrapped safety proposal for semi-trucks means they can zoom down US highways at top speed

Freak hailstorm batters Croatia as wildfires rage in Balkan countries

Man dies in tragic incident on Milan airport runway

Voices: As the world gets more dangerous – the UK has to build peace through aid as it prepares for war

Who is Brigitte Macron? The wife of French President Emmanuel Macron’s wife to join him on state visit

Philippines summons China's ambassador after Beijing sanctions critical former senator

Trump live: President admits Aug 1 tariff deadline could be extended again after demanding deals from allies

Putin will attack Nato country to keep Europe distracted while Xi invades Taiwan, warns Rutte

Trump compares himself to Truman after Iran attack

Suspect in shooting of Slovakia’s PM appears in court on terror charges

UK sanctions Russian weapons bosses for role in Ukraine war

Tragic picture shows entire cabin of Camp Mystic girls and counsellors swept away in Texas floods - as death toll rises to over 100

Donald Trump says US will send more weapons to Ukraine after Putin rejects peace talks

Norman Tebbit, former Tory cabinet minister under Thatcher, dies aged 94

The expert guide to creatine, the supplement said to make you smarter and stronger

Britain is already a prime target for Russia and China – and we are not ready

I’ve seen how we’d respond to a nuclear attack on British soil – it’s devastating

I’ve been a war correspondent for decades – I’m more worried than ever about our safety

Musk's America Party has helpers — and challenges

Managers were already disappearing. Enter AI.

Bill would force ICE agents to ID themselves, ban them from wearing masks

Elon Musk's Trump fallout poses deepening risks to Tesla, SpaceX

Scoop: Senate Republican super PAC smashes fundraising record

Inside Trump's Patriot missile plans for Ukraine

Monsoon floods sweep away 18 people and the main bridge linking Nepal to China

Cairo telecom building fire kills 4 and injures 26

Suspect in shooting of Slovakia’s populist leader Fico stands trial on terror charges

Srebrenica women bury loved ones but remain haunted by memories of 1995 massacre

Officer who shot Australian Aboriginal teen Kumanjayi Walker was racist, inquest finds

Jeffrey Epstein seen shortly before his death in new footage

RFK Jr. promoted a food company he says will make Americans healthy. Their meals are ultraprocessed

Lizard Island coral death reaches 92 per cent after 2024 bleaching event, study finds

Latest ‘Tiger King’ twist as star faces 10 years in prison

Trump gushes over Netanyahu after Nobel Peace Prize nomination: ‘An honour coming from you’

What is going on with Trump’s tariffs? All you need to know as trade deal deadline delayed again

First photos of deadly beef wellington meal cooked by Erin Patterson released

Iran's government says at least 1,060 people were killed in the war with Israel

I sneered at friends’ non-traditional relationships – now I’m the only one divorced

Six no-fly day trips to Europe that are cheaper and faster than a UK train ticket

Japanese Emperor Naruhito meets Mongolian president to boost ties

Mexico's president calls march against mass tourism 'xenophobic'

Colombia's president backtracks on accusations against US officials in letter to Trump

Residents wear masks as volcanic ash blankets villages near erupting volcano

Mexican authorities seize nearly 4 million gallons of stolen fuel

Turkey's youngest oil wrestlers keeping a 14th-century tradition alive

Amazon Prime Day 2025: Shop these top deals before they’re gone!

Emmie Silbery dead: Gogglebox star dies as heartbreaking final six-words revealed

Israeli PM Netanyahu reveals he's nominated Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize

Hull City’s rollercoaster has run out of track

The 10 minutes that showed the Lionesses can get their Euros back on track

I’m 52 and Oasis are getting me through my marriage breakdown