Even some Republicans are questioning Netanyahu's plan to have Israel occupy Gaza City

Some congressional Republicans are raising questions about Israel's planned occupation of Gaza City as pro-Israel Democrats push back on the operation with unusual ferocity.Why it matters: Israel's coalition of political allies in the U.S. has become scrambled in recent weeks amid a growing humanitarian crisis is Gaza — and a coinciding drop in U.S. public opinion towards Israel. Lawmakers sympathetic to Israel are warning that the plan could be a logistical nightmare and warning the country to tread carefully and avoid further alienating the international community.It's not just Democrats questioning the plan: "I'd like to know who is actually going to run it," Rep. Tim Burchett (R-Tenn.), a member of the House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee that oversees the Middle East, told Axios.Rep. Ryan Zinke (R-Mont.), another member of the panel, told Axios: "Occupation for security also comes with the responsibility of providing humanitarian assistance and creating an economic future."State of play: The Israeli security cabinet on Thursday approved Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's proposal to have the IDF "take control" of Gaza City in an effort to defeat Hamas.In addition to occupying Gaza City, which is expected to take months and displace around 1 million Palestinian civilians, the IDF will also be charged with distributing humanitarian aid, Axios' Barak Ravid reported.The IDF's chief of staff pushing back during the cabinet meeting by arguing the plan could endanger Israeli hostages in Gaza and lead to protracted Israeli military governance.President Trump, who has split with Netanyahu on allegations of famine in Gaza, is not planning to intervene to oppose the operation.Driving the news: Rep. Brad Schneider (D-Ill.), the chair of the roughly 100-member New Democrat Coalition and a vocal pro-Israel centrist, called the plan "tactically questionable and strategically self-defeating.""If implemented, the decision is more likely to play into Hamas's original objectives in starting this war and further unite much of the world against Israel than it is to bring home the last surviving hostages and advance the security needs of the nation," Schneider said in a statement.Rep. Ritchie Torres (D-N.Y.), one of Democrats' staunchest Israel backers, said in a statement that Israel is the "ultimate arbiter of its own security" but that "the war in Gaza is in danger of becoming a quagmire."Drawing comparisons to the protracted American conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan, Torres urged Israel to maintain a narrow focus on securing the release of the remaining hostages.Yes, but: Israel is still not without its unflinching Republican supporters in Congress."In the absence of a ceasefire, which Hamas repeatedly rejects, Israel is left with no choice," Rep. Mike Lawler (R-N.Y.), the chair of the Foreign Affairs middle east subcommittee, told Axios."If everyone agrees Hamas cannot remain in power and the hostages must be released, how do you expect to get there? Who is going to force that? The UK? France?"Said Rep. Don Bacon (R-Neb.): "There will be no peace with Hamas. Until Hamas is rooted out and the hostages returned, I understand the need to occupy Gaza. Hamas started this war and did this to themselves."

Comments

World news

Democrats say Congress should hear from Epstein victims, not just Maxwell and the Clintons

Independent

Jeffrey Epstein 'loved life too much' to kill himself and must have been murdered, his butler says as he spills the beans on everyone who visited - from Prince Andrew to Bill Clinton

about 3 hours ago

Mexico’s President Says U.S. Forces Are Unwelcome in Her Country

newyorktimes

Melania Trump celebrates as Democratic strategist apologizes and removes parts of podcast that alleged Epstein connection

about 4 hours ago

President slaps his name on Armenia-Azerbaijan peace passage: The Trump Route for International Peace and Prosperity

Independent

Comments

Similar News

Trust in Zelenskyy is diminished even after reversal of law that fueled protests

Ukraine-Russia war latest: Trump says he will meet Putin even if Kremlin leader won’t meet Zelensky

The Texas gerrymandering showdown is about to get even messier

Even Trump’s former Surgeon General has hit out at RFK Jr’s plans to gut vaccine research: ‘Going to cost lives’

The jobs report is a big deal. Trump’s response is an even bigger one.

Flash floods cause havoc across Asia even as July temperatures ebb

Why Recognizing Palestine Is Meaningless or Even Harmful

US labour data agency was teetering even before Trump fired its chief

The Supreme Court just revealed its plan to make gerrymandering even worse

Three chef-approved recipes for summer evenings, from lobster salad to club sarnies

Musk funneled $15 million to Trump and Republicans even as they were dragging each other through the mud in online feud

The champion English women’s soccer team is scoring new fans — even men

North Vancouver councillor wants fees for over-budget sewage plant spread more evenly

Commentary: Dying babies. Starving adults. Even Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene is calling it a "genocide"

Trump is making plans to avoid an RBG situation on the Supreme Court, his next picks could be even more right-wing

Europe’s entry fee for visitors is going up — before it even starts

Why even Trump isn’t buying Netanyahu’s preposterous claim on Gaza’s starvation crisis

Chaos over Alina Habba’s status at the NJ attorney’s office even has defendants confused

Why even Trump isn’t buying Netanyahu’s preposterous claim on Gaza’s starvation crisis

Nigeria kidnappers kill 35 hostages even after ransom paid

World news

Democrats say Congress should hear from Epstein victims, not just Maxwell and the Clintons

Kristi Noem is offering teenagers student loan forgiveness if they sign up to be an ICE agent

Ukrainian troops have little hope for peace as Trump's deadline for Russia arrives

Trump’s DOJ subpoenas NY AG’s office for files on Trump’s civil prosecution and case against NRA

DOGE tore through National Weather Service like a tornado with mass firings. Many are being rehired

Solo travellers, here’s why September is the best time for a European holiday

Trump has no interest in stopping Netanyahu – he just wants to avoid a headache

4 questions as British man accused of ‘affair with daughter-in-law he tried to drown’

Landlord MPs to earn more than £4m in rent from tenants

Trump’s State Department Reforms Are Necessary