Florida ordered to undo Alligator Alcatraz due to environmental risks

A federal judge in a ruling Thursday night prohibited state and federal officials from bringing new detainees to Alligator Alcatraz, the hastily built immigration detention site in the Everglades.The ruling also demanded the state begin dismantling elements of the facility — including temporary fencing, lighting fixtures and generators, among other equipment — within 60 days.Why it matters: U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams' 82-page ruling delivers a blow to Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and President Trump, who applauded the facility and encouraged other states to replicate it.Catch up quick: Shortly after DeSantis administration officials announced plans for the facility, environmental groups and the Miccosukee Tribe sued, arguing it violated the National Environmental Policy Act.The law requires that environmental studies be conducted before any "major" federal action or construction project.The groups had requested that the site be temporarily shut down while the lawsuit played out.Construction was paused earlier this month, following a judge's order.Both the DeSantis and Trump administrations have said the facility has had zero impact on the environment, citing the airstrip that was already on the site before they built the facility.Yes, but: The court cited expert testimony that repurposing the site has resulted in "a myriad of risks" to its sensitive surroundings, including runoff and wastewater discharge that could harm the Everglades.She noted testimony indicating the new lighting alone had reduced the habitat for the protected Florida panther by 2,000 acres.Williams also noted that testimony from the Miccosukee Tribe indicated that its members lost access to trails they'd previously used for hunting and harvesting ceremonial and medicinal plants.The bottom line: Williams concluded the state failed to evaluate the impact of expanding that airstrip into a detention facility and "consulted with no stakeholders or experts and did no evaluation of the environmental risks.""Here, there weren't 'deficiencies' in the agency's process," Williams wrote. "There was no process."What they're saying: "This is a landmark victory for the Everglades and countless Americans who believe this imperiled wilderness should be protected, not exploited," said Eve Samples, executive director of Friends of the Everglades, one of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit."It sends a clear message that environmental laws must be respected by leaders at the highest levels of our government — and there are consequences for ignoring them."The other side: Shortly after the ruling was issued, Florida's Division of Emergency Management executive director Kevin Guthrie appealed.The federal Department of Homeland Security didn't immediately respond to a request for comment.More from Axios:Alligator Alcatraz leans on myth steeped in racismInside Alligator Alcatraz, Florida's immigrant detention facilityFlorida spent more than $200 million to set up Alligator Alcatraz, records show

Comments

World news

Adults are happy for Happy Meals: Here’s why so many are ordering off the kids’ menu

Independent

Comments

Similar News

Rainbow crosswalk outside Florida Pulse nightclub where 49 LGBT+ people were killed is removed overnight on Trump’s orders

Hurricane Erin approaches U.S., prompting warnings from Florida to New York

Florida man accused of setting off his sprinklers at disabled children because he was mad about their bus stop

Florida grandma accused of plotting with son to murder her daughter’s husband goes on trial

Florida man who fatally stabbed friend over Trump convicted of second-degree murder

Semi-truck driver arrested after making illegal U-turn on Florida highway killing three people

Florida continues capital punishment record with execution date for triple murderer

Execution date set for Florida man who killed estranged wife’s sister and parents, set fire to house

‘State-driven censorship’: new wave of book bans hits Florida school districts

Ron DeSantis enters the chat: governor eyes chance to redraw Florida maps

Prosecutors clear Florida officer in violent arrest of Black man at traffic stop

Florida mom ‘lucky to be alive’ after miscarrying due to raw milk consumption, she says in lawsuit

Rapper Sean Kingston to be sentenced for $1 million fraud scheme in South Florida

Florida elementary school teacher accused of drunkenly crashing car between classes

Florida governor says state will open ‘deportation depot’ immigration jail

Florida opening Deportation Depot at former prison to operate alongside Alligator Alcatraz

Florida AG announces ban on "7-OH" products

Wildlife groups condemn approval of ‘barbaric’ Florida black bear hunt

Cops fear baby may be ‘in danger’ as they launch search for pair linked to man’s murder in Florida

Florida county official accused of killing grandfather in hospice care with sleeping pill overdose

World news

Adults are happy for Happy Meals: Here’s why so many are ordering off the kids’ menu

Trump bizarrely boasts he knows ‘more about grass than any human being’ during DC photo op with troops

Ukraine-Russia war latest: Trump says Kyiv needs to ‘fight back’ after Putin launches massive serial assault

At least 17 dead after car bombing and helicopter attack

Florida ordered to undo Alligator Alcatraz due to environmental risks

Hurricane Erin brings "life-threatening" surf and rip conditions to U.S. East Coast

Oliveira, Collaros lead Bombers to 2nd straight victory in Montreal

British citizen arrested in Ibiza for using stolen UK car in holiday heists

Thai Court to Rule in Thaksin’s Royal Defamation Case

‘Flying Blind’: Trump Strips Government of Expertise at a High-Stakes Moment

Gavin Newsom signs bill to redraw California districts in response to Texas effort to add five GOP seats

Erik Menendez denied parole almost four decades after murdering parents with brother

Trump threatens "harsh measures" against Colorado if Tina Peters is not freed from prison

Trump admin vetting 55 million U.S. visa holders for potential deportation violations

New visas paused for commercial truck drivers, Rubio says

Alina Habba "unlawfully appointed" New Jersey AG, federal judge rules

Why Germany's top football league is turning to this man

Friends of Kelowna man evicted while experiencing health issues speak out

Victoria pediatric urgent care clinic to close amid staff burnout

Summer storms leave a trail of destruction in central Saskatchewan

A year after Chilcotin landslide, concerns remain for both river and salmon

Trump Budget Office Is Withholding H.I.V. Funds That Congress Appropriated

Slain woman’s family launches advocacy campaign to prevent intimate partner violence deaths

How to speak Trump: World leaders are bringing gifts and stroking president’s ego to get access ... and their way

White House rattled by one Smithsonian painting it claims proves Trump’s ‘out of control’ claims

Trump backs huge Arizona copper mine as Apache win late reprieve to halt it

In the Middle East, a Cold War Redux?

The Supreme Court hands down some incomprehensible gobbledygook about canceled federal grants

U.S. Rep. Lloyd Doggett of Texas says he'll bow out if redistricting stands

Newsom signs California redistricting measures in response to Texas bill

Pope Leo’s first international trip could be to Lebanon, cardinal says

Rwanda-backed rebel group M23 denies role in Congo massacres

Uganda agrees deal with US to take deported migrants without criminal records

Grand ceremony and parade mark 60 years of Chinese Communist Party rule in Tibet

Explosion at Pakistan fireworks storage facility injures at least 25 people

Uganda agrees deportation deal with the US on condition that deportees should not have criminal records

Israel to continue with Gaza City offensive despite talks to free Hamas hostages

It's been a confusing week - and Trump's been made to look weak

Ontario college support staff take step toward strike with ‘no board’ request

Trade war could kill 1 in 5 B.C. small businesses within 6 months: CFIB

Surrey wants your help to make sure every student has school supplies this fall

Southern Alberta farm devastated by hailstorm, loses beloved camel

Must-have tennis gear and accessories for every kind of player

Saskatoon Hilltops rebound to 1-1 record with help from third-string QB McMahon

B.C. ostrich cull over avian flu exposure can proceed, federal appeal court rules

“Lost in translation” Alberta Premier says she was unaware of controversial expense changes

RRC adapting to changing industries by offering new programs

Lake Okanagan Resort residents push for new water treatment plant, following McDougall Fire

Meet the Emmy-winning B.C. mountain bike film studio that gets the ‘crazy shots’

'It's pretty straightforward': Danielle Smith objects after Ontario man charged with assaulting home intruder

Salvadoran man arrested at airport while trying to self-deport receives punishment: deportation

Murder victim’s daughter testifies about chilling statements her father allegedly made about how to hide a body

Trump attorney Alina Habba has no ‘lawful authority’ to serve as New Jersey’s top prosecutor, judge says

Trump touts perceived wins while praising ‘healthy, attractive people’ on DC federal patrol photo op

‘Cruel hoax’ prompts Villanova University students to shelter in place after false ‘active shooter’ reported on campus

How Many Peace Deals Has Trump Actually Brokered?

Trump Sanctions More ICC Officials