Schools scramble to police AI cheating

High schools and colleges are stuck in limbo: Use of generative AI to cut corners and cheat is rampant, but there’s no clear consensus on how to fight back.Why it matters: AI is here to stay, forcing educators to adapt.That means sussing out when students are using it — and avoiding the temptation of overusing it themselves."I have to be a teacher and an AI detector at the same time," says Stephen Cicirelli, an English professor at Saint Peter’s University in Jersey City, N.J. "[Any assignment] that you take home and have time to play around with, there's going to be doubt hanging over it."Cicirelli captured the zeitgeist with a viral post on X about how one of his students got caught submitting an AI-written paper — and apologized with an email that also appeared to be written by ChatGPT."You're coming to me after to apologize and do the human thing and ask for grace," he says. "You're not even doing that yourself?"By the numbers: Use is ubiquitous in college. A survey of college students taken in January 2023, just two months after ChatGPT's launch, found that some 90% had already used it on assignments, New York Magazine reports.1 in 4 13- to 17-year-olds say they use ChatGPT for help with schoolwork, per a recent Pew survey. That’s double what it was in 2023.Driving the news: The proliferation of AI-assisted schoolwork is worrying academic leaders.66% think generative AI will cut into students’ attention spans, according to a survey of university presidents, chancellors, deans and more from the American Association of Colleges & Universities and Elon University's Imagining the Digital Future Center.59% say cheating has increased on campus. 56% say their schools aren't ready to prepare students for the AI era."It's an undeniable and unavoidable disruption," says Lee Rainie, director of Elon's digital future center. "You can't avert your eyes."One big snag: Teachers can't agree on what’s acceptable in this new world.For example, 51% of higher education leaders say it’s fine for a student to write a paper off a detailed outline generated by AI, while the rest say it’s not or they don’t know, per the AAC&U and Elon survey.Policies vary from classroom to classroom within the same school.Plus, the rise of AI is causing unforeseen headaches.Teachers run assignments through detectors, which often don't get it right, either missing AI-generated work or mistakenly flagging original work as written by AI. Students who didn't use AI have had to appeal to their schools or submit proof of their process to avoid getting zeroes, The New York Times reports.Instructors are getting caught leaning on ChatGPT, too. One Northeastern senior demanded tuition reimbursement after discovering her professor had used AI to prep lecture notes and slides, according to The New York Times.The other side: As much as they're struggling to wrangle AI use, many educators believe it has the potential to help students — and that schools should be teaching them how to use it.American University's business school is launching an AI institute for just that purpose. "When 18-year-olds show up here as first-years, we ask them, 'How many of your high school teachers told you not to use AI?' And most of them raise their hand," David Marchick, the dean of American University's Kogod School of Business, told Axios' Megan Morrone. "We say, 'Here, you're using AI, starting today.'"ChatGPT can be a real-time editor and refine students' writing or speed up research so they can focus on organizing big ideas instead of information gathering, Jeanne Beatrix Law, an English professor at Kennesaw State University, writes in The Conversation."Don't block AI ... Instead, let's put in place some of the same safety and wellness protocols that it took us a decade to build for social media and web 1.0," says Tammy Wincup, CEO of Securly, a software company that builds safety tools for K-12 schools.What to watch: "There is a gigantic question across academic institutions right now," Rainie tells Axios. "How do you assess mastery?"Cicirelli says he's asking students to draft their work in Google Docs so he can see the brainstorming and writing process.In-class assessments, like oral exams or essays written in old-fashioned Blue Books, are already becoming more common.

Comments

World news

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy says $12.5bn for air safety upgrades isn’t nearly enough: ‘We need it now’

Independent

Trump administration denies critically ill 4-year-old is being deported and says humanitarian request under consideration

about 2 hours ago

FBI announces investigation after LGBT advocates clash with Christian groups at Seattle’s city hall

Independent

Comments

Similar News

Former University of Manitoba student attacked in dorm files lawsuit against school

What Macron’s ‘disturbing’ slap REALLY reveals about marriage to wife, 72, after school affair saw pals spit on her door

Three men traveled half way across the country to photograph an abandoned school. Then a SWAT team was called

Supreme Court denies student's right to wear 'only two genders' T-shirt at school

Advocacy group calls for relief measures for Guelph schools without air conditioning

Trump threatens to move $3 billion in federal grants from Harvard to trade schools

Israeli air strike hits school in Gaza with children burned alive in classroom

Alberta changing rules to ensure ‘age appropriate’ books in schools

Young girl escapes burning Gaza school after Israeli attack

Israeli strikes kill 52 in Gaza including 36 in a school-turned-shelter, medics say

15-year-old injured after being hit by vehicle in Mississauga school parking lot

Israeli Strikes Kill 52 In Gaza, Including 36 In A School-Turned Shelter, Medics Say

Texas House approves bill requiring Ten Commandments to be displayed in public schools

Gaza horror as Israel launches missile strike on school-turned-shelter 'killing dozens' including children

Students, staff return to Ontario school after crash killed 4 teens and coach

Israeli attack on school used as shelter in Gaza kills dozens, say local health officials – Middle East crisis live

Estonia eschews phone bans in schools and takes leap into AI

At least 20 reported dead in Israeli airstrike on Gaza school housing displaced people

Barbara Kay: Antisemitism plagues Canadian medical schools. It isn’t healthy

Who is Andriy Portnov? Former Ukrainian politician killed on school run in Spain

World news

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy says $12.5bn for air safety upgrades isn’t nearly enough: ‘We need it now’

Lucky pull: Gambler wins $1.8 million on $5 bet from slot machine at Vegas airport

Marco Rubio announces US will begin yanking visas of Chinese students

As Trump pardons fraudsters, MAGA grasps at straws with Biden’s ‘autopen’

US trade court rules Trump exceeded his authority with ‘Liberation Day’ tariffs

Trump team makes it easier to invest 401(k)s in crypto. Some experts say that’s a bad idea

Stylist testifies that ‘frightened’ Cassie Ventura wanted to jump off hotel balcony to escape Diddy

Watery grave of Bayesian superyacht revealed in eerie last photos as mystery sinking sparks multi-million war of words

US court blocks Trump from imposing sweeping global tariffs - claiming he exceeded his authority

Pensions megafunds to boost average savers pot by £6,000, Reeves claims

Manitoba government declares state of emergency as wildfires rage

Closing arguments in Thomas Hamp’s murder trial wrap up Wednesday

Canadian doctors group challenging constitutionality of Alberta transgender law

Calgary researchers using ‘citizen science’ for a study on invasive mosquitoes

Red flag watch: Alberta Wildfire warns of intense, dangerous conditions to come

Police respond to ‘serious’ collision involving bus at Horseshoe Bay

Terrifying video captures moment massive glacier crashes down mountain and buries village

Donald Trump explodes in furious rant at Vladimir Putin over Ukraine peace talks

Trump Holds Off on New Russia Sanctions

Donald Trump’s tariffs on Canada, world blocked by U.S. trade court

Nvidia's earnings surged but chip export restrictions dealt a blow

Trump's sweeping global tariffs blocked by federal court

U.S. believes breakthrough is close on Gaza ceasefire, hostage deal

5 parts of Trump's budget bill that risk being axed by Senate rules

EU lifts most Syria sanctions but slaps new ones on alleged culprits in attacks on Alawite civilians

Furious Trump lashes out at Putin over Ukraine talks: ‘He’s playing with fire!’

Mom faces charges after cops say she tried multiple times to kill her 8-year-old autistic son

Nancy Mace ran bot army, had staff run fake accounts to boost profile, report claims: ‘It’s what she does for fun’

Josh Duggar ‘signing autographs’ for fellow inmates behind bars while serving child porn sentence

Supreme Court declines to hear Josh Duggar’s child porn appeal

Trump administration denies critically ill 4-year-old is being deported and says humanitarian request under consideration

FBI announces investigation after LGBT advocates clash with Christian groups at Seattle’s city hall

‘It’s all God and President Trump’: Grateful Chrisleys’ daughter awaits dad at prison after reality TV couple’s pardon

Portugal's Chega party becomes the main opposition and joins Europe's far-right surge

Canadian swimmer Summer McIntosh to train with Michael Phelps' coach. What we know about the move

Swiss town BURIED after horror avalanche thunders down mountain in huge landslide & submerges homes & causes evacuation

The cost of a pardon

Brit mum killed in horror crash as she celebrated on dream Jamaican holiday

Brit, 79, faces huge sentence in notorious hellhole jail if meth drug mule claim proved

The areas where new reservoirs will be built confirmed

Young students lend a hand at Okanagan animal sanctuary

Pandemonium as 2 pigeons take over Delta plane cabin, panicking passengers

Thousands on evacuation order in northern Manitoba due to wildfires

B.C.’s new, Indigenous-led grizzly bear stewardship framework inches towards finish line

COVID shot is safe during pregnancy, Canadian doctors say after U.S. move

Tate brothers face rape and trafficking charges in U.K.

Glacier Collapse in the Swiss Alps Destroys Most of a Village

Campaigns running to address ‘period poverty’ in the Maritimes

Trump's attacks on law firms are losing big in court

What to know about a cholera outbreak in Susan that has killed over 170 people

Tate brothers face rape and trafficking charges in the U.K.

Southeast Asia's illicit methamphetamine trade is at a record high, the U.N. says

Trump says Russia-Ukraine deal could come soon

A new variant of COVID-19 may be driving up cases in some parts of the world, WHO says

Senior Canadian diplomat compares Trump's Golden Dome missile program to a 'protection racket'

White House submitting new peace proposal toward ending Israel-Hamas war

Gov. DeSantis signs law imposing tougher penalties for abandoning pets during disasters