Trump's Powell attacks show why Fed was designed to be independent

Three things can simultaneously be true: that it would be reasonable for the Federal Reserve to cut interest rates; that its headquarters renovation is too expensive; and that the Trump administration's attacks show why central banks are designed to be independent in the first place.The big picture: The whole reason the U.S. and other advanced economies grant their central banks a measure of independence is to instill confidence that they won't make policy based on what's most convenient in the near-term for elected leaders — such as cutting rates to save the fiscal authorities cash.Yet that is exactly the grounds President Trump has repeatedly invoked as the reason he believes the Fed should cut rates drastically.Driving the news: Bloomberg reported Wednesday that a White House official said Trump is likely to attempt to fire Fed chair Jerome Powell soon. CBS News reported that Trump circulated the idea to receptive Congressional Republicans on Tuesday.State of play: The 3-percentage-point rate cut Trump has called for would put the Fed's policy in ultra-stimulative mode at a moment when unemployment is low, inflation remains elevated, and tariffs threaten a new price surge in the months ahead.The core of the argument playing out right now — and potential litigation, should Trump attempt to fire Powell for cause — is whether the U.S. will stick with its tradition of handing control over the money supply to technocrats as opposed to the president.Between the lines: It's an important new chapter in the nation's long, tumultuous history with central banking.That includes key moments like Andrew Jackson's war with the Second Bank of the United States in the 1830s and the Treasury-Fed accord of 1951 that delineated the roles of the two institutions in managing government debt.Yes, but: That doesn't mean that the Fed is getting things exactly right, either in its monetary policy or its real estate decisions.There is a pretty solid case for interest rate cuts right now, even if not the one Trump makes, and $2.5 billion truly is a massive amount of money to spend on renovating a couple of historic buildings.Zoom in: The argument for rate cuts that could persuade independent-minded technocrats isn't tied to Trump's calls to save the federal government money on borrowing costs, but rather something rooted in current economic conditions.The argument would hold that the Fed's current target interest rate, around 4.4%, is still in territory that officials consider "restrictive," deliberately slowing economic activity to try to bring down inflation.But inflation has been mostly on a gradual downward path for three years now and is not far from the Fed's 2% target. Tariffs might create a price surge, but that should be a one-time event that policymakers ought to look past.Moreover, there are growing signs of weakness in the labor market, including low hiring rates and weak job creation in cyclical sectors.Zoom out: The Fed's renovation — fueled by overhauling its historic 1935 headquarters building on the National Mall and a second historic building next door, with a tunnel connecting the two — really is costing a lot of money, ultimately borne by taxpayers.But it's also the case that the Federal Reserve Act gives the Board of Governors independent authority over its real estate precisely to insulate it from political pressure.And the Trump administration has left little doubt that the president's discontent over rates is driving the new scrutiny of the project.What they're saying: "If the Fed were to lower interest rates this month to 1%, White House officials would stop talking about beehives and fancy elevators," Sarah Binder, a political scientist at George Washington University who has studied Fed governance, tells Axios.If Trump attempts to remove Powell from his job for cause before his term expires 10 months from now, it would set up a legal battle — very likely ending up before the Supreme Court — with long-term consequences for how U.S. economic policy is run.The bottom line: "How far would the Court be willing to go to insulate the Fed if Powell were charged with 'neglect of duty?'" Binder asks. "Remains to be seen!"

Comments

World news

Independent

Judge orders arrest of ‘Chimp Crazy’ star as she faces sentencing for perjury

about 2 hours ago

Independent

University of Michigan faces federal investigation after two Chinese students arrested for smuggling biological materials

about 2 hours ago

Dad of crypto king mysteriously vanished in LA. Then ‘creepy texts’ from him started to arrive in the family group chat

Independent

Firefighter volunteers from Mexico crossed border to help Texas flood victims: 'This was a mission to come and help our brothers'

about 2 hours ago

Inferno engulfs main stage at Tomorrowland Festival in Belgium

Metro

NIH executive fired amid allegations of steering $3.3 million contract to company that named his wife as a potential staffer

about 4 hours ago

20 states sue the Trump admin for cutting disaster prevention money

Independent

Trader Joe’s are being targeted by ‘extreme’ animal rights groups in California - with protestors allegedly posing as employees

about 4 hours ago

The push to defund Planned Parenthood hit other clinics in Maine. Now their group is suing

Independent

Comments

Similar News

Trump trade representative pushes defence start-ups to fill manufacturing gap

ICE is now richer than most of world’s militaries thanks to Trump’s new funding

Trump Embraces State Capitalism

Trump makes it personal with MAGA over Epstein

Carney Moves to Reduce Canada’s Chinese Steel Imports in Response to Trump’s Tariffs

Trump administration sued by 20 states for cutting disaster prevention grants

Trump could lose the ‘bros’ that helped him win election over Epstein fallout, pundits warn

PEPFAR keeps millions of people with HIV alive and may be spared from Trump spending cuts

Newsmax mocks ‘terrified’ Fox News for avoiding the Epstein story: ‘Don’t want to p*ss off’ Trump

Laura Loomer warns Trump’s Epstein flub could ‘consume his presidency’

Why Trump has turned his back on Putin - somewhat

Wall Street rides roller-coaster after Trump walks back talk of firing Powell

Trump says he discussed firing Fed chair but 'highly unlikely' he will

Trump asked lawmakers whether he should fire Fed’s Powell

Trump attacks own supporters over Epstein conspiracies

Trump privately indicates he may soon fire Fed chair Jerome Powell

Donald Trump Jr-led online gun store known on Wall Street as ‘PEW’ launches stock offerings

Trump calls it ‘highly unlikely’ he’ll fire Fed chair Powell after reportedly telling House GOP he ‘likely will soon’

Trump attacks ‘stupid Republicans’ for wanting Epstein files released

20 states sue the Trump admin for cutting disaster prevention money

World news

Judge orders arrest of ‘Chimp Crazy’ star as she faces sentencing for perjury

University of Michigan faces federal investigation after two Chinese students arrested for smuggling biological materials

Dad of crypto king mysteriously vanished in LA. Then ‘creepy texts’ from him started to arrive in the family group chat

PEPFAR keeps millions of people with HIV alive and may be spared from Trump spending cuts

Trump could lose the ‘bros’ that helped him win election over Epstein fallout, pundits warn

Passengers reach settlement in $1 billion lawsuit over Alaska Airlines flight where door plug blew out at 16,000 feet

Newsmax mocks ‘terrified’ Fox News for avoiding the Epstein story: ‘Don’t want to p*ss off’ Trump

Laura Loomer warns Trump’s Epstein flub could ‘consume his presidency’

New Jersey woman whose friend’s boyfriend posted stolen intimate photos of her online gets $8.7 million payout

Firefighter volunteers from Mexico crossed border to help Texas flood victims: 'This was a mission to come and help our brothers'

Inferno engulfs main stage at Tomorrowland Festival in Belgium

Reeves blamed for UK inflation bump as NI rise hits food prices

The Open 2025 schedule, tee times, prize money and how to watch

Afghan data breach risks pushing more asylum seekers onto small boats

The gross incompetence of the Afghan leak knows no end

Rachel Reeves’s Mansion House speech ignored the one thing everyone was thinking about

EU chief unveils new $2.3 trillion budget. Lawmakers say the math doesn't 'add up'

Bill would prevent ICE from detaining or deporting U.S. citizens

Why Israel is getting involved in Syria's internal fighting

Why Trump has turned his back on Putin - somewhat

Deadly crush at Gaza aid site after new system implemented

Wall Street rides roller-coaster after Trump walks back talk of firing Powell

Ford, Carney governments told to ‘do some homework’ on duties to First Nations

2 men to serve jail time then be deported for Surrey hit-and-run dragging death

Five highlights from 2025-26 NHL schedule

North Edmonton playground fire as arson: Police

Winnipeg Jets announce 2025-26 regular season schedule

Mum of Michael Frison receives chilling mystery messages year after son vanished

Tomorrowland festival main stage engulfed in flames as fireworks heard

Trump says he discussed firing Fed chair but 'highly unlikely' he will

'Sparring in space' – BBC gains rare access to US base tracking global missile strikes

The Impact of Fewer Babies Being Born in Countries Around the Globe

Mosaic of Lovers, Taken by Nazi Officer, Is Returned to Pompeii

Police reveal how five-year-old fell from Disney cruise ship before father jumped in to saved her

Donald Trump Jr-led online gun store known on Wall Street as ‘PEW’ launches stock offerings

Pie Company that appeared on ‘Shark Tank’ files for bankruptcy

Trump calls it ‘highly unlikely’ he’ll fire Fed chair Powell after reportedly telling House GOP he ‘likely will soon’

Trump administration deported ‘monsters’ to tiny African country in deal catching diplomats by surprise

Over 50% of kids who die in cars were left there unknowingly. Forgetting your own child is easier than you may think

Iceland volcano eruption: Watch lava shoot from 2km-long fissure

Trump attacks ‘stupid Republicans’ for wanting Epstein files released

The Trump administration’s latest immigration target: Kids aged 11 and under

Man charged with killing Minnesota lawmaker plans to plead not guilty

NIH executive fired amid allegations of steering $3.3 million contract to company that named his wife as a potential staffer

20 states sue the Trump admin for cutting disaster prevention money

After decades of division, can this European country finally find peace?

Ford recalls almost 700,000 vehicles over fuel injector faults

Kentucky restaurant sued and accused of starting ‘beaver fever’ outbreak that has sickened 23

Trader Joe’s are being targeted by ‘extreme’ animal rights groups in California - with protestors allegedly posing as employees

The push to defund Planned Parenthood hit other clinics in Maine. Now their group is suing

Criminal inquiry launched after six-year-old boy ‘kills newborn baby’ in France

Cuban minister resigns after saying beggars in the country were all fakes

Plane passenger caught arguing on flight after seat given away to a child

Bookish cast, TV channel and episode guide for Mark Gatiss murder mystery series

Starmer gets tough: How suspending rebels sends message to MPs over SEND reforms

Man Utd eye Jackson swap deal with Chelsea in bid to offload Garnacho

The BBC is a master of responding to its own mistakes