Why I withdrew my book from an LGBTQ+ literary prize | Jason Okundaye

The Polari first book prize claims to promote trans rights and trans voices. But when I saw the longlist, I had to actLast week, I withdrew my nomination from the longlist for the Polari first book prize. The awards had become mired in controversy due to the nomination of the Irish author John Boyne, best known for The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, for the main prize for his novel Earth. Four days before the longlist announcement, Boyne had written in the Irish Independent, celebrating JK Rowling “as a fellow terf” and saying of women who had “pilloried” her for her gender activism: “For every Commander Waterford, there’s a Serena Joy standing behind him, ready to pin a handmaiden down as her husband rapes her.”I think such a viewpoint is abhorrent, but Boyne is free to hold whatever views he wants. What was unacceptable was a statement from the Polari prize addressing the backlash, emphasising its commitment to “support trans rights and amplify trans voices”, but defending Boyne’s inclusion on the grounds that submissions are assessed purely “on the merits of craft and content” and that “within our community, we can at times hold radically different positions on substantive issues”.Jason Okundaye is an assistant newsletter editor and writer at the Guardian. He edits The Long Wave newsletter and is the author of Revolutionary Acts: Love & Brotherhood in Black Gay BritainDo you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here. Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

Alaska meeting was a start, but Putin is still up to his old tricks — and Trump knows it

'She was so f***ed up': Carolyn Bessette's friends tell MAUREEN CALLAHAN of her secret Daddy issue, JFK Jr's murder brag that drove her mad... and why everything we know about her is a lie

Sad truth about ageing men... every woman whispers about it. So many women put up with these ludicrous husbands: AMANDA PLATELL

British viewers are not sufficiently 'classy' to enjoy Meghan's Netflix series and are 'too cynical' unlike Americans: Incendiary claim of Harry's friend revealed by RICHARD EDEN... and he doesn't stop there!

ANDREW NEIL: The world is being remade. And as the Alaska talks show all too clearly, Britain and Europe are now condemned to the status of mere observers

Brooklyn Democratic Party hacks’ support of Zohran Mamdani is really about the next council Speaker and patronage

What we make of the Trump-Putin meeting: Vlad’s not ready for peace — but our prez still sees hope of getting there

Want to fix the nation’s broken higher-ed system? Look to the South

Gloucester Township’s parental accountability law: Letters to the Editor — Aug. 16, 2025

Even the most devoted ‘Sex and the City’ fans were disgusted and disappointed by ‘And Just Like That’ — the Fyre Festival of TV shows

ANDREW PIERCE: Was Afzal Khan's visit to Cyprus a bid to save his seat as he faces battle against Corbyn's new party?

ROBERT HARDMAN: Queen Camilla's tears as VJ Day hero salutes King Charles

Stop anti-Trump judges, it’s still the economy, stupid and other commentary

Trump’s DC crime crackdown is saving the city — and its lawless kids

Fresh proof the federal workforce is still stuck on #Resisting Trump

Letters to the Editor: Habit can claim anything it wants, but In-N-Out is still the king of burgers

It’s the Age of Trump — and he’s forging a new political era

Letters to the Editor: Is anyone surprised that oil refineries are leaving California?

Churchill’s bunker

We should hang our heads in shame over how Australia treated our diggers today. The few WWII survivors who remain deserved far better

Brooklyn and Harry are a pair of wet wipes who lack the gumption to stand up for the families who love them: JAN MOIR

Labour's war on boomers: Gordon Brown stole your old age, now Starmer and Reeves plan to finish the job, writes RICHARD LITTLEJOHN

'Temu' Taylor Swift is so busy pumping out terrible music, she may have just let slip how she and Travis will end! We all need a break from this tired showgirl: KENNEDY

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: End of an era as sonless Sir Benjamin Slade turns his mansion over to hotel group

Eric Adams is right — we need involuntary treatment to solve the public drug scourge

Scott Bessent’s sudden visit to IRS office — with whistleblowers — sends strong message just days after sixth commish was ousted

The week in whoppers: Bernie Sanders defends Hamas, Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson’s nutty hit on Trump and more

Polls show what Trump knew — the Jeffrey Epstein saga is an elite obsession

Little Sisters of the Poor are still fighting ObamaCare— as states force nuns to violate their faith

Delusional Jussie Smollett remains as shameless as ever as he points the finger of blame at everyone else

Craven and dishonest: Behind the Toronto bid to censor an Oct. 7 documentary

Democrats’ twisted lies about Melania’s past are cruel and creepy

The State Education Department HATES letting the public learn from test results

Liverpool WON'T win the title - and Man United's glaring weakness could cost them again: IAN LADYMAN shares his Premier League predictions

Trump’s war on DC crime: Letters to the Editor — Aug. 15, 2025

Contributor: A climate report without denial and without excessive alarm bells

Contributor: How many kids must die before L.A. makes streets safer?

First Farage, now Jenrick, the BBC pandering to the extremists does nothing to dial down the temperature

I am being tortured by restless leg syndrome. This is the only thing that brings me relief - but I wish there was another way: BRYONY GORDON

Don't believe the gushing nonsense you're hearing about Meghan and Harry's Netflix deal, says RICHARD EDEN. I've been told the truth... and it's VERY different

I paid next door's British Gas bill thanks to smart meter mistake: CRANE ON THE CASE

Miranda Devine: Bumbling Obama aides actually admit Russiagate was a smear campaign against Trump

Oh. My. God. Albo comment about what Hamas wants leaves egg all over PM's face: PETER VAN ONSELEN

Yes, I've been caught speeding but don't dare tell me I can't drive just because I'm old: JENNI MURRAY

Labour's class war is about to get worse. This mean and petty act takes your money from your children. Could Rachel Reeves be so stupid? Yes she could: STEPHEN GLOVER

Where does Trump go when he needs a little vacation?

Ignore the blowhard activists— keep horse carriages in Central Park

America has PLENTY of reason to believe Adam Schiff schemed to smear Trump

Ukraine peace is in reach — if Trump meets Putin’s demands with US vigor

Next target for our arrogant, ignorant ‘experts’: organ donors

Mamdani’s ‘public safety’ agenda is barely even voodoo

Big Brother is watching you — but this homeowner made him back down

The corner bakery with the BEST hot sauce you'll ever taste + Byron Bay's adults-only secret and Australia's bougiest travel trackies: THE DETOUR

Palestine statehood is a cruel fiction, Democrats need a new agenda ASAP and other commentary

MAUREEN CALLAHAN: Meghan's most galling hypocrisy yet... and a looming new Kate Middleton clash. Did she really think we wouldn't notice?

How was a subway hijacking teen arrested 12 times and let go by judges 5 times in just a year? Toxic empathy

Letters to the Editor: Mountain lion attack reminds us of the need to peacefully coexist with wildlife

Rachel Reeves is coming after your inheritance, this is what you should do NOW to protect yourself, writes SIMON LAMBERT

Marcus Rashford claims United are in 'no-man's land' but the same goes for him - he had the chance to be part of the solution and blew it: RIATH AL-SAMARRAI

I was mistakenly added to the school moms' group chat... the messages about my new body enhancement were the most hurtful: DEAR JANE