The Last Of Us Season 2 Finale Confirms A Huge Missed Opportunity

Bella Ramsey as Ellie in The Last Of Us season twoSpoilers for The Last Of Us season two finale ahead.Turning The Last of Us Part II into a grounded, prestige TV show was always going to be difficult. After all, for every touching line of dialogue and brutal narrative twist, there’s a platforming puzzle to solve or a combat challenge that doesn’t translate easily from PlayStation to HBO.However, one of the biggest issues facing the writing team of The Last Of Us was undoubtedly how to deal with the game’s unique narrative structure. Based on the season two finale, it looks like the HBO show has already failed to meet that challenge.The Last Of Us Part II video game’s brilliant twistIn the game, you play through the first half of its roughly 24-hour experience as Ellie while she embarks on a mission of vengeance to find and kill Abby. But at the story’s midpoint, when the two characters finally come face-to-face, it dramatically shifts perspective.The game suddenly forces the player to control Abby instead, as we learn what she’s been up to during the same stretch of time. In the context of a video game, where you have to physically control your character for the story to progress, this works brilliantly. When the shift first happens, players may be repulsed at the thought of helping Abby through her own adventures. But by the end of the game, it’s no longer clear which character is the hero of this story — or which is the villain.Speaking to IndieWire in 2020, the game’s creative director, Neil Druckmann, explained the thinking behind this approach.“There’s something interesting that happens when you’re not in alignment with the character and the game makes you do something that you don’t want to do,” he said.“You wrestle with those decisions in a different way than you would be able to in a passive medium.”This makes sense. In a video game like The Last Of Us Part II, the experience of playing as a character you’ve grown to hate felt unique and innovative. But, in the more passive format of television, it’s not exactly a new idea. Villains and anti-heroes have been the focal point of prestige TV shows for decades. HBO even helped define the concept with The Sopranos, proving audiences could learn to love a vulgar murderer — if the writing was good enough.So while HBO’s The Last Of Us isn’t heading into uncharted territory, it still feels like a missed opportunity to live up to the game’s level of creativity.Kaitlyn Dever as Abby in The Last Of Us.How the TV version of The Last Of Us adapts that twistAt the start of season two, The Last Of Us made a few changes to the story. Most notably, while the game kept Abby’s identity and motives shrouded in mystery over many hours of play, the drama spelled them out for its audience early on. In a later episode, the series also gave us more info about a pivotal conflict between the militarised Washington Liberation Front and the cult-like Seraphites than the game would have at that point. These subtle narrative changes felt like a sign of things to come. Maybe the series wouldn’t rely so heavily on the same types of twists that fuelled the game. However, now that we’ve reached the season finale, it’s clear that was never the plan.The final shot of The Last Of Us season two flashes back several days in the story, while shifting the perspective from Ellie (Bella Ramsey) to Abby (Kaitlyn Dever). It’s clear we’re about to see the same few days play out in season three, but now from Abby’s perspective instead of Ellie’s, ultimately bringing us back to their confrontation in the season two finale. While it’s an intriguing cliffhanger, it’s a disappointing reveal for anyone hoping the show would find a new way to retell the game’s story.To be clear, Abby’s adventure is a great one. It’s full of complex characters and powerful emotional beats that rival anything we’ve seen so far on The Last Of Us. I just wish HBO had been more willing to mix up the way its narrative unfolds. Because while it works in the video game, I’m still not convinced those same tricks can carry over to prestige TV.The Last Of Us is streaming on Now and Sky in the UK.READ MORE:The Last Of Us Creator's Update On The Show's Future Is The Best News Fans Could Ask ForThe Last Of Us Star Names 1 Part Of Season 2 Sex Scene That Was Actually Her IdeaJennifer Aniston Was As Surprised As We Were By Her Appearance In The Last Of Us

Comments

Breaking news

Metro

Furious neighbours of King Charles's Highgrove say they have nowhere to leave their cars due to hordes of tourists - despite paying for one of Britain's most expensive parking permits

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Colombian presidential hopeful in critical condition after being shot during assassination attempt

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Police launch probe after baby passes away at home in 'unexplained' death

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Scientists issue urgent warning to festivalgoers over terrifying new drug that's 500 TIMES stronger than heroin - as two people die from suspected overdoses in Britain

about 2 hours ago

Female traveller reveals reason she feels safer in Spain than in the UK

Dailymail

Elon Musk has 'PTSD from the White House' and believes he's 'made a mistake' by helping Donald Trump get reelected, his father Errol claims

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

I'm a celebrity hairdresser - this is the very common mistake people make and what to do instead for perfect holiday hair

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Kemi Badenoch says she refuses to meet burka-clad constituents as Tories back allowing bosses to ban female staff from wearing Islamic veils

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Reform's economic policies are 'Liz Truss on steroids', says Tory Chris Philp (who backed her mini-Budget as a Treasury minister)

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Chris Hughes' ex-girlfriend reveals she's pregnant just days after former Love Island star confirmed romance to JoJo Siwa

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

The chilling ways your alarm clock, photo frames and smoke alarms are spying on you: Secret recordings are on the rise...and it's NOT against the law

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Drug kingpin gunned down in Costa del Sol bar with Scottish gangster was 'seen as top dog by rival cartels' - before having £250k bounty put on his head

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Father-of-three is 'sliced to death' by razor-sharp popular children's toy

about 2 hours ago

Comments

Breaking news

Major high street brand with over 250 UK stores ‘at risk of collapse’

Colombian presidential candidate ‘fighting for his life’ after assassination attempt

Man found dead inside car outside Asda in Leicester

Minister Peter Kyle Boldly Compares Labour's Arrival In Government To Steve Jobs' Apple Takeover

Minister Laughs Off New Football Chant Which Takes Aim At Starmer With 4-Letter Word

Jane Austen Fans Share Her 9 Best TV And Movie Adaptations Of All Time

Laura Kuenssberg Calls Out Top Tory After He Refuses To Apologise For Liz Truss's Mini-Budget

Man dies in Birmingham after fall from landmark city building

No decision on winter fuel allowance until autumn, minister says

Chad announces suspension of visas to US citizens in response to Trump travel ban

Israeli fire ‘kills 4 Palestinians’ near Gaza aid sites

Molly Russell’s father urges PM to act over online harms as ‘app cap’ considered

Spending review: Schools to get more funding but police warned to ‘do their bit’

Revealed: Home Office pays migrants £53m to leave UK

Weight-loss jabs may need to be taken for life, experts warn

Russia continues to accuse Ukraine of delaying planned exchange of dead fighters

Kyrgyzstan removes towering Lenin statue from second city

Zelensky says Russia is ‘ignoring all peace proposals’ after ‘brutal’ Kharkiv attack

Why a bat in the attic could see home improvement costs go through the roof

Putin plotting to blitz Ukraine with ‘vicious & unrelenting’ revenge strike in days after Op Spiderweb, US insiders warn

Average age Brits meet their ‘best friend for life’ is revealed in new study

Inside Lucy Letby’s diaries cops used to snare baby killer – & why expert thinks secret code PROVES her innocence

Brazen owner of Bully which mauled boy, 5, blames child and insists ‘he’s harmless…I still let him play with my toddler’

Mystery as man dies in car after being found ‘unresponsive’ outside Asda car park

New Ryanair, easyJet and Wizz Air bag rules coming for Spain and Greece

Baby found dead as police probe 'unexplained' incident at home

You could be fined £100 for common driveway mistake - or lose insurance

John Swinney shrugs off calls to quit as SNP leader after Hamilton by-election disaster

Weight-loss doctor has warning over barbecue food that's a 'calorie bomb'

Moon to turn red this week in best Strawberry Moon until 2043

'Entitled friend blocked me online after I didn't help her move home'

Is Rachel Reeves the next Steve Jobs?

Water cremation and human composting could be offered instead of traditional funerals

Dead body found in Leicester Asda car park as police launch probe

Fears big cat prowling in sleepy Worcestershire town as mutilated corpse discovered

Meghan Markle would've 'horrified' King with 'astonishing' move as she 'clings' to title

Brit backpacker, 24, could face 20 years in prison over Australian e-scooter crash

Weight-loss doctor says barbecue food you think is healthy is a 'calorie bomb'

Sir Nick Faldo takes swipe at UK while bragging about Donald Trump friendship

Date night dressing: His and hers outfit ideas from £34 that take inspo from celeb couples

'I picked normal names for my daughters but in-laws say they're disgusting'

Labour minister hits back at X-rated chanting about Keir Starmer during England game

Foreign Office issues warning to anyone staying overnight in Greece

Squirming Tory refuses FOUR times to apologise for Liz Truss chaos in excruciating BBC clash

Chef shares simple one-ingredient recipe for 'zero-carb' crisps

Furious neighbours of King Charles's Highgrove say they have nowhere to leave their cars due to hordes of tourists - despite paying for one of Britain's most expensive parking permits

Colombian presidential hopeful in critical condition after being shot during assassination attempt

Police launch probe after baby passes away at home in 'unexplained' death

Scientists issue urgent warning to festivalgoers over terrifying new drug that's 500 TIMES stronger than heroin - as two people die from suspected overdoses in Britain

Female traveller reveals reason she feels safer in Spain than in the UK

The mind-boggling reason most US game shows are filmed in IRELAND against all odds - and it's bad news for Hollywood

Netflix film based on real-life murder rockets to top of charts as impressed viewers gush 'bravo to everyone involved!'

Elon Musk has 'PTSD from the White House' and believes he's 'made a mistake' by helping Donald Trump get reelected, his father Errol claims

I'm a celebrity hairdresser - this is the very common mistake people make and what to do instead for perfect holiday hair

Kemi Badenoch says she refuses to meet burka-clad constituents as Tories back allowing bosses to ban female staff from wearing Islamic veils

Reform's economic policies are 'Liz Truss on steroids', says Tory Chris Philp (who backed her mini-Budget as a Treasury minister)

Chris Hughes' ex-girlfriend reveals she's pregnant just days after former Love Island star confirmed romance to JoJo Siwa

The chilling ways your alarm clock, photo frames and smoke alarms are spying on you: Secret recordings are on the rise...and it's NOT against the law

Drug kingpin gunned down in Costa del Sol bar with Scottish gangster was 'seen as top dog by rival cartels' - before having £250k bounty put on his head

Father-of-three is 'sliced to death' by razor-sharp popular children's toy