The Last Of Us Season 2 Finale Confirms A Huge Missed Opportunity

Bella Ramsey as Ellie in The Last Of Us season twoSpoilers for The Last Of Us season two finale ahead.Turning The Last of Us Part II into a grounded, prestige TV show was always going to be difficult. After all, for every touching line of dialogue and brutal narrative twist, there’s a platforming puzzle to solve or a combat challenge that doesn’t translate easily from PlayStation to HBO.However, one of the biggest issues facing the writing team of The Last Of Us was undoubtedly how to deal with the game’s unique narrative structure. Based on the season two finale, it looks like the HBO show has already failed to meet that challenge.The Last Of Us Part II video game’s brilliant twistIn the game, you play through the first half of its roughly 24-hour experience as Ellie while she embarks on a mission of vengeance to find and kill Abby. But at the story’s midpoint, when the two characters finally come face-to-face, it dramatically shifts perspective.The game suddenly forces the player to control Abby instead, as we learn what she’s been up to during the same stretch of time. In the context of a video game, where you have to physically control your character for the story to progress, this works brilliantly. When the shift first happens, players may be repulsed at the thought of helping Abby through her own adventures. But by the end of the game, it’s no longer clear which character is the hero of this story — or which is the villain.Speaking to IndieWire in 2020, the game’s creative director, Neil Druckmann, explained the thinking behind this approach.“There’s something interesting that happens when you’re not in alignment with the character and the game makes you do something that you don’t want to do,” he said.“You wrestle with those decisions in a different way than you would be able to in a passive medium.”This makes sense. In a video game like The Last Of Us Part II, the experience of playing as a character you’ve grown to hate felt unique and innovative. But, in the more passive format of television, it’s not exactly a new idea. Villains and anti-heroes have been the focal point of prestige TV shows for decades. HBO even helped define the concept with The Sopranos, proving audiences could learn to love a vulgar murderer — if the writing was good enough.So while HBO’s The Last Of Us isn’t heading into uncharted territory, it still feels like a missed opportunity to live up to the game’s level of creativity.Kaitlyn Dever as Abby in The Last Of Us.How the TV version of The Last Of Us adapts that twistAt the start of season two, The Last Of Us made a few changes to the story. Most notably, while the game kept Abby’s identity and motives shrouded in mystery over many hours of play, the drama spelled them out for its audience early on. In a later episode, the series also gave us more info about a pivotal conflict between the militarised Washington Liberation Front and the cult-like Seraphites than the game would have at that point. These subtle narrative changes felt like a sign of things to come. Maybe the series wouldn’t rely so heavily on the same types of twists that fuelled the game. However, now that we’ve reached the season finale, it’s clear that was never the plan.The final shot of The Last Of Us season two flashes back several days in the story, while shifting the perspective from Ellie (Bella Ramsey) to Abby (Kaitlyn Dever). It’s clear we’re about to see the same few days play out in season three, but now from Abby’s perspective instead of Ellie’s, ultimately bringing us back to their confrontation in the season two finale. While it’s an intriguing cliffhanger, it’s a disappointing reveal for anyone hoping the show would find a new way to retell the game’s story.To be clear, Abby’s adventure is a great one. It’s full of complex characters and powerful emotional beats that rival anything we’ve seen so far on The Last Of Us. I just wish HBO had been more willing to mix up the way its narrative unfolds. Because while it works in the video game, I’m still not convinced those same tricks can carry over to prestige TV.The Last Of Us is streaming on Now and Sky in the UK.READ MORE:The Last Of Us Creator's Update On The Show's Future Is The Best News Fans Could Ask ForThe Last Of Us Star Names 1 Part Of Season 2 Sex Scene That Was Actually Her IdeaJennifer Aniston Was As Surprised As We Were By Her Appearance In The Last Of Us

Comments

Breaking news

Los Angeles anti-ICE protests: Trump threat against ‘riots and looters’ after immigration raids spark fury on LA streets

Independent

Comments

Breaking news

Los Angeles anti-ICE protests: Trump threat against ‘riots and looters’ after immigration raids spark fury on LA streets

Presidential candidate shot and seriously wounded in Colombia

Faster drug treatments and longer-lasting batteries to come from &#163;86bn spending review package

National Guard to be deployed to immigration 'riots' - as Trump claims state officials 'can't do their jobs'

Body coach Joe Wicks' 'simple and healthy' breakfast with delicious Italian staple

Crunch talks with President Trump over a US-UK trade deal in doubt over new Chinese 'super-embassy' in London, with the White House said to be 'very concerned'

The expensive funds that ARE worth paying for

Ruthless people smuggler who charges £1,200 to transport migrants to the UK boasts: 'French gendarmes do nothing. Do not worry. I am the police'

More than nine of out ten of the Tory rank-and-file want Kemi Badenoch to purge 'wets' from the party in order to meet the challenge of Nigel Farage and Reform UK

Major update after human remains were found in search for Pheobe Bishop - and the key clues cops have yet to find

Revealed: Shocking story of Harrow-educated fraudster who paid Britney £1m to jump out of cake, gave Leonardo DiCaprio £250,000 to party with him and handed Kim Kardashian £275,000... and now he's mysteriously missing

The day my dead daughter visited me from the spirit world and gave me irrefutable evidence to prove it. Military chief SUZANNE GIESMANN'S family tragedy changed her life. Now she tells how our loved ones never really leave

As Labour risks a civil libertires backlash by hinting ID cards are in the pipeline, the party's former Home Secretery argues... All our digital fingerprints are everywhere, so giving a national identity card to every citizen is a no-brainer

Trump sends National Guard to Los Angeles amid chaos in the streets as protesters clash with ICE agents

Diddy makes desperate move to have case tossed over claims he dangled fashion designer off 17-story balcony

Diana star Emma Corrin swaps A-list Rami for stage sidekick Zachary Hart... and who should they bump into but Sherlock star Benedict Cumberbatch

George Orwell estate accused of censorship after putting trigger warning at start of Nineteen Eighty-Four

British sailor arrested in Portugal on suspicion of attempted murder 'after throwing girlfriend who couldn't swim into river'

20 years on from the febrile aftermath of London's 7/7 bombings, a heart-stopping minute by minute account of the day Scotland Yard's first ever shoot-to-kill operation ended in the... CATASTROPHIC death of an innocent man

White House warns Downing Street against letting China build 'super embassy' near sensitive financial sites

So much for smashing the gangs! Starmer claims the secret to solving the small-boat crisis is a crackdown on people smugglers, but soft-touch French judges let them walk free from court with merely a slap on the wrist

Business is buzzing for couple behind revival kits that rescue bees in need... while Wimbledon serves up an ace rival to strawberries with its very own honey

Not only does sleep recharge your batteries - it might also stop you going deaf in your old age

Kemi Badenoch says office managers should be able to ban women from wearing face coverings

One of NHS's biggest AI projects is halted after fears it used health data of 57 MILLION people without proper permissions

King Charles will swap reins for carriage at Trooping the Colour ceremony as he continues undergoing treatment for cancer

How women blighted by cruel back pain may actually have hidden arthritis - as doctors reveal there's a simple drug cure that can end the agony. Special report by ETHAN ENNALS

'How can Geri rubbish the legacy of the Spice Girls... who does she think she is?': As furious row erupts, sources VERY close to the band tell KATIE HIND their withering verdicts on 'lady of the manor' Geri

STEPHEN POLLARD: Labour's created an atmosphere where the hard working middle class are now fair game for bigotry

Liver disease is on the rise in the UK due to soaring obesity levels, but a 10-minute stroll each day can help stop it in its tracks

Brit pop icon Adele thanks Netflix hit Adolescence for 'changing her relationship with her son' in heartwarming letters

Italian citizenship referendum polarises country

British woman accused of killing Australian in e-scooter crash

Trump orders National Guard into LA after protests over immigration raids

Hunt for Father Accused of Killing 3 Daughters Expands in Washington Forest

Colombian Senator Shot at Campaign Event

Sovereignty beats Journalism to win the Belmont Stakes at Saratoga

PHOTO COLLECTION: Best of French Open Tennis Finals

Obama’s doctor says Biden’s physician should have given him cognitive tests

PHOTO COLLECTION:World Pride Parades

Leftie teachers, cops and doctors trying to swerve court trans ruling named & shamed in damning report

‘Fuming’ Angela Rayner locked in ‘tense’ row with Rachel Reeves over crucial spending review

Donald Trump slams ‘big-time drug addict’ Elon Musk as toxic feud intensifies

Grooming gangs national inquiry demands grow as Tories force vote on new probe into ‘disgusting’ crimes

Illegal immigrants hide on coach taking pupils to France on school trip – as stowaway journeys surge

John Swinney to host THIRD summit on youth violence epidemic in Scotland

Orkney primary school teaching post vacant since March 2019, figures show

Inside the tower block so dangerous residents face being kicked out at any moment

Body found at beach identified as dad reported missing nine weeks prio as family pay tribute

‘I have muscular dystrophy - That doesn't mean I can't have a love life’

SOLVED: Decades-old mystery of the ballroom photo that featured in one of the most famous films of all time... but do you remember where you've seen it?

Russian shells on Kharkiv leave four dead and 60 injured - including a baby - after 'most powerful attack since the start of the war in Ukraine'

Taxpayer foots huge bill to prosecute 66-year-old grandmother for accidentally smashing the leg off a neighbour's garden gnome... that she'd already tried to pay for

As long as it twerks in America! Why Meghan Markle doesn't care if British 'haters' winced at video of her twerking in the delivery room before daughter Lilibet's birth

Labour at war over spending plans as Number 10 tries to stem threat from Farage

The NHS recoups just £29million for treating European patients... while forking out £1billion in return

Chris Martin leaves fans in frenzy after cryptic shout-out to Dakota Johnson on stage amid split

Pioneering device could help patients with Parkinson's, which affects 150,000 people in the UK, to walk again

MARK LITTLEWOOD: A full-blooded agenda can help revive the Tory Party's fortunes - but we must act fast

Two years after breaking down in front of thousands at Glastonbury, Lewis Capaldi is to make his big stage return at this year's festival

Faster drug treatments and longer-lasting batteries to come from £86bn spending review package