The Last Of Us Season 2 Finale Confirms A Huge Missed Opportunity

Bella Ramsey as Ellie in The Last Of Us season twoSpoilers for The Last Of Us season two finale ahead.Turning The Last of Us Part II into a grounded, prestige TV show was always going to be difficult. After all, for every touching line of dialogue and brutal narrative twist, there’s a platforming puzzle to solve or a combat challenge that doesn’t translate easily from PlayStation to HBO.However, one of the biggest issues facing the writing team of The Last Of Us was undoubtedly how to deal with the game’s unique narrative structure. Based on the season two finale, it looks like the HBO show has already failed to meet that challenge.The Last Of Us Part II video game’s brilliant twistIn the game, you play through the first half of its roughly 24-hour experience as Ellie while she embarks on a mission of vengeance to find and kill Abby. But at the story’s midpoint, when the two characters finally come face-to-face, it dramatically shifts perspective.The game suddenly forces the player to control Abby instead, as we learn what she’s been up to during the same stretch of time. In the context of a video game, where you have to physically control your character for the story to progress, this works brilliantly. When the shift first happens, players may be repulsed at the thought of helping Abby through her own adventures. But by the end of the game, it’s no longer clear which character is the hero of this story — or which is the villain.Speaking to IndieWire in 2020, the game’s creative director, Neil Druckmann, explained the thinking behind this approach.“There’s something interesting that happens when you’re not in alignment with the character and the game makes you do something that you don’t want to do,” he said.“You wrestle with those decisions in a different way than you would be able to in a passive medium.”This makes sense. In a video game like The Last Of Us Part II, the experience of playing as a character you’ve grown to hate felt unique and innovative. But, in the more passive format of television, it’s not exactly a new idea. Villains and anti-heroes have been the focal point of prestige TV shows for decades. HBO even helped define the concept with The Sopranos, proving audiences could learn to love a vulgar murderer — if the writing was good enough.So while HBO’s The Last Of Us isn’t heading into uncharted territory, it still feels like a missed opportunity to live up to the game’s level of creativity.Kaitlyn Dever as Abby in The Last Of Us.How the TV version of The Last Of Us adapts that twistAt the start of season two, The Last Of Us made a few changes to the story. Most notably, while the game kept Abby’s identity and motives shrouded in mystery over many hours of play, the drama spelled them out for its audience early on. In a later episode, the series also gave us more info about a pivotal conflict between the militarised Washington Liberation Front and the cult-like Seraphites than the game would have at that point. These subtle narrative changes felt like a sign of things to come. Maybe the series wouldn’t rely so heavily on the same types of twists that fuelled the game. However, now that we’ve reached the season finale, it’s clear that was never the plan.The final shot of The Last Of Us season two flashes back several days in the story, while shifting the perspective from Ellie (Bella Ramsey) to Abby (Kaitlyn Dever). It’s clear we’re about to see the same few days play out in season three, but now from Abby’s perspective instead of Ellie’s, ultimately bringing us back to their confrontation in the season two finale. While it’s an intriguing cliffhanger, it’s a disappointing reveal for anyone hoping the show would find a new way to retell the game’s story.To be clear, Abby’s adventure is a great one. It’s full of complex characters and powerful emotional beats that rival anything we’ve seen so far on The Last Of Us. I just wish HBO had been more willing to mix up the way its narrative unfolds. Because while it works in the video game, I’m still not convinced those same tricks can carry over to prestige TV.The Last Of Us is streaming on Now and Sky in the UK.READ MORE:The Last Of Us Creator's Update On The Show's Future Is The Best News Fans Could Ask ForThe Last Of Us Star Names 1 Part Of Season 2 Sex Scene That Was Actually Her IdeaJennifer Aniston Was As Surprised As We Were By Her Appearance In The Last Of Us

Comments

Breaking news

Inside story: How Labour's triumph in Hamilton has left the SNP and Swinney reeling

The Herald

Landlords' sickening find in property rented by couple accused of murdering Pheobe Bishop - and the brutal way they learned their house had been completely trashed

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Shocking rise of 'Ozempic HANDS': New disturbing side effect of weight-loss jab leaving celebrities looking 'like the undead'

about 2 hours ago

Gory details of Elon Musk's 'rugby tackle' of Scott Bessent spill out as White House leaks escalate

Dailymail

Comments

Breaking news

Inside story: How Labour's triumph in Hamilton has left the SNP and Swinney reeling

Corporation did its best for Glasgow and does not deserve this flak

Cops feel ‘coerced' to log suspects by gender identity and not sex says whistleblower

'Hostile and discriminatory': Students speak out over trans rights row

Regulator probes Scots charity over funding of St Mirren execs' failed damages claim

Ukrainian and Scottish artists team up for Glasgow festival exploring sound

St Mirren land dispute judgment a 'crucial precedent' for Scots free speech

Rich people ‘will have robot butlers by 2030′ – but there’s a major flaw

Steve Bannon Calls Musk ‘National Security Issue,’ Says He 'May Be Here Illegally'

Overwhelmed By Clutter? The 'Pick Up Every Item' Method Can Help

8 Movie Tropes That Seem Fake But Insiders Say Are 100% Real

Miley Cyrus Talks About The Tattoos She Regrets The Most

I Told My Tween Daughter I Snuck Into A ‘Diddy Party’ When I Was 17 – Her Response Was Perfect

Harrison Ford Went Out Of His Way To Compliment 1 Of His Co-Star's 'Great D**k'

Trump: Musk Faces 'Serious Consequences' If He Backs Dems Over Budget Bill

Saying These 2 Words Can Keep Kids Safe Around Pools On Holiday

Raising school fees torments many Africans. Some expect the Catholic Church to do more to help

French Open: Defending champion Alcaraz faces No. 1 Sinner for the men's title

Colombian presidential candidate in 'critical condition' after attempted assassination

Trump seizes opportunity to deploy federal force in California

Trooping the Colour 2025: Major change for King Charles at this year's ceremony

Ex-Loose Women's Saira Khan credits 'glowing skin' to one affordable food

Graduate, 25, found stabbed to death in ditch as lies of killer, 84, exposed

Heartbroken family's horror after finding someone else's face during hospital post-mortem

Kate Middleton's title 'almost went to another royal' before major switch up

'I was a superfit karate Black Belt who didn't drink or smoke - it didn't stop cancer'

'I cried after saying goodbye to my Butlins lover - 33 years later we were married'

'I found the perfect 'blonzing' product for summer and it rivals rhode's popular blushes'

‘I dialled the wrong number and found my future husband'

Next drops designer-looking cow print trainers that rival Adidas’ sell-out styles

Landlords' sickening find in property rented by couple accused of murdering Pheobe Bishop - and the brutal way they learned their house had been completely trashed

Shocking rise of 'Ozempic HANDS': New disturbing side effect of weight-loss jab leaving celebrities looking 'like the undead'

Gory details of Elon Musk's 'rugby tackle' of Scott Bessent spill out as White House leaks escalate

'Let him grow' - Ronaldo and Yamal to meet on Sunday

Tottenham return is unrealistic - Pochettino

'I couldn't imagine not teaching full-time - until I had my baby'

England beat West Indies to complete ODI series clean sweep

'It doesn't get any bigger' - Sinner & Alcaraz set for French Open showdown

Trump’s Self-Dealing Is More Alarming Than You Think

Trump threat to LA over ICE protests echoes his notorious ‘the shooting starts’ quote during Black Lives Matter demos

Travel ban may shut door for Afghan family to bring niece to US for a better life

Boulder Jewish Festival proceeds with enhanced security and focus on healing after attack

Tony Awards offer many intriguing matchups in a star-studded season

Celtic Park Snoop Dogg burger bar plan revealed by rap superstar

Keir Starmer's military expansion could boost Scottish economy

Disposable vapes ban flouted across Scotland including shops linked to Anas Sarwar's family's firm

Keir Starmer’s defence expansion plan 'will bring tens of billions of investment into Scotland'

Paedo lawyer worked at charity accused of ignoring child sex harassment claims

Swinney accused of 'deliberate and sinister' tactics in by-election

NHS chiefs gave £250k bonus to firm behind infection scandal QEUH hospital

Shock Sky sale slashes Google Pixel to lowest price yet

Scots MP blasted for accepting cash donation from lobbyist

Fatcat uni boss who told MSPs he didn’t know his own salary spent £47k on luxury foreign junkets

Thug who tried to strangle ex-girlfriend avoids jail again after assaulting cop

Madeleine McCann: Former detective brands search 'pointless' and based on 'sketchy' information

Primark's 'stylish' £5 bag could be mistaken for £90 Ted Baker version

Today's horoscope for June 8 as Aries is left disappointed

UK weather: Britain facing 29C SCORCHER in just days as maps turn fiery red across England

Innocent man who spent 17 years in prison for rape he didn't commit ‘not finished’ fighting

Top of the crops: Famous faces star in veggie lookalike show