From The Salt Path To Baby Reindeer – What Does 'True Story' Mean Legally?

"The Salt Path" - South West England Gala ScreeningLast year, Netflix hit Baby Reindeer got into some hot water over the framing of its episodes as a “true story.” And now, The Observer’s investigation into The Salt Path (a book which sold over two million copies and was adapted into a film starring Gillian Anderson and Jason Isaacs) has called its self-described “honest” and “true” nature into question. The publication explored the idea that the book, written by Raynor Winn, may have lied about everything from her and her partner’s names to the cause of their financial woes. Records appear to show that the pair, whose long walks while homeless were the focus of the book, may have had a home in France the whole time; meanwhile, neurologists have shed doubt on the husband, James’s, diagnosis. In a statement shared with The Telegraph, author Raynor Winn said: “[The] Observer article is highly misleading. We are taking legal advice and won’t be making any further comment at this time.”But where does “truth” begin and end in art? What weight does the “emotional truth” Baby Reindeer creators cited carry, and is there a legal difference between “based on a true story” and “this is a true story” in TV, books, and films?“Based on a true story” and “this is a true story” are not the same The Observer said that at the time of writing (5 July), The Salt Path’s publisher still described the book as “unflinchingly honest” and “true” on their site.This is still the case as I write this (7 July).According to Nakia Gray, a media and intellectual property lawyer with Locked & Lawyered Firm, “based on a true story” and “a true story” are legally distinct terms. “The former signals to the audience that while the story draws inspiration from real events or people, creative liberties have likely been taken – it’s a disclaimer of sorts,” she tells HuffPost UK.“The latter is a much bolder claim and could expose the filmmaker to greater legal risk if the portrayal is inaccurate or defamatory, especially when living individuals are involved.” Previously, a real-life chess player who sued Netflix for The Queen’s Gambit, which they say misrepresented parts of their career.Grey continues, “These labels impact everything from defamation defences to whether someone portrayed in the story can successfully sue for misrepresentation or invasion of privacy.“In short: those few words carry serious legal weight.”There are many terms which allude to truth but don’t promise itOn an episode of The Rest Is Entertainment, journalist Marina Hyde pointed out that the intro line to Wicked Little Letters, which claimed the events which unfolded in the series were “more true than you’d think,” was allowed because the story is “something that happened in the 1920s” and everyone depicted in the film is now dead.It’s therefore not considered possible to libel them.Legally speaking, she added, “no individual holds the legal right to the story of their own life”.“As long as you’ve obtained the information legally and without any sort of subterfuge, then you are free to make a story about anything,” she continued.But that right competes with other people’s right not to be defamed, which is why, co-host Richard Osman said, “based on” is always the safer bet. Related...So THAT's Why UK Heatwaves Feel So Much Worse Than Other Countries11 Classic Movies People Think Aged Like Fine Wine11 Jobs Movies Always, Always Get Wrong

Comments

Breaking news

London Journal

Gold medals in Malaysia, “Garvi Gujarati Thali” as well as “World Peace” Machtail was shocked by the taste of Gujarati food.

about 2 hours ago

MS Dhoni Birthday: Like the same end, from the World Cup to IPL title, a look at Dhoni’s career

London Journal

Ex-forecasters at National Weather Service defend Texas meteorologists and say warnings were as timely as they should have been

about 2 hours ago

American kids have become increasingly unhealthy over nearly two decades, new study finds

Independent

Comments

Breaking news

Gold medals in Malaysia, “Garvi Gujarati Thali” as well as “World Peace” Machtail was shocked by the taste of Gujarati food.

MS Dhoni Birthday: Like the same end, from the World Cup to IPL title, a look at Dhoni’s career

‘Death date’ of universe revealed as scientists predict when ‘shrinking’ will start before ‘Big Crunch’ wipes us all out

Business Idea: Just one deal and ₹ 1.5 lakh in your pocket, this is the real game of business

Couple ‘disgusted’ after discovering Morrisons cheese is crawling with maggots

Mysterious ‘glowing orb’ eerily hovers over couple’s home in Canada

Mushroom killer accused of ‘tampering with with prison food and making inmate sick’

‘I spent a fortune building dream home but now the council won’t let me live in it’

UK Gardeners Urged To Pee In Watering Cans For 2 Surprising Benefits

Former Russian Minister Found Dead In Car After Being Sacked By Putin

Squid Game Season 3: Creator Reveals Why He Changed His Mind About The Finale's Ending

Do Dads Sleep Through Their Babies' Cries At Night?

Squid Game Fans Spot Sneaky Final Season Easter Egg And They're Stunned

Greece detains 1,200 migrants in three days as arrivals from Libya surge

The Latest: Camp mourns loss of 27 in Texas flash floods that killed dozens

Paris couture week opens with Cardi B holding a live crow at Schiaparelli’s spectacle

Anti-woke activist applauds his ‘friends’ at the New York Times for Zohran Mamdani college application ‘scoop’

Elon Musk calls DOJ findings that there was no Epstein ‘client list’ the ‘final straw’

Why Keir Starmer could face a fresh rebellion over disability support for Send children

Flooding from Chantal's remnants forces dozens to flee homes in North Carolina

Wimbledon: Novak Djokovic overcomes a poor start to beat Alex de Minaur and reach the quarterfinals

Researchers warn planned C-section births — the most common surgery in the US — can increase risk of childhood cancers

Starmer in race against time to secure Trump tariff carve-out as deadline looms

Man killed after shooting at a US Border Patrol facility in southern Texas

PHOTO COLLECTION: Texas floods leave dozens dead and missing as rescuers search devastated landscape

Jaguar Land Rover sales tumble after pausing US exports

Ex-forecasters at National Weather Service defend Texas meteorologists and say warnings were as timely as they should have been

American kids have become increasingly unhealthy over nearly two decades, new study finds

Iris Van Herpen unveils 'living' couture dress of bioluminescent algae in Paris

A Vermont dairy farm was raided. The mixed messages from Washington since then have increased fears

Inquiry launched into government handling of Harry Dunn’s death, Lammy announces

Voices: ‘Lofty ambition, very little detail’: Readers react to Labour’s 10-year plan for the NHS

Three dead and ten hurt after gunmen start firing randomly in Philadelphia neighborhood

Russia's ex-minister found dead hours after being fired, investigators believe he killed himself

TfL sells sponsorship rights for entire Tube line in multi-million pound branding deal

Tesla shares slump amid Elon Musk’s America Party and President Trump drama

Unusual bee attack in French town leaves 24 injured, 3 critically

Labour’s pension plans remind me of communist China, says Lloyds chief

‘Discussions continue’ over US steel tariffs deal ahead of deadline, says No 10

Celebrity birthdays for the week of July 13-19

Wimbledon’s expansion plan in High Court after local residents react with fury

Why is Wimbledon blaming human error for a mistake by its new electronic line-calling system?

Retailer Dunelm to appoint Clodagh Moriarty as chief executive

‘Without EHCP, my son would not be here’: Mother’s plea to Labour against proposed SEND cuts

New research suggests women in midlife can benefit from ‘gym bro’ supplement

Trump plans to visit Texas later in the week after devastating floods have killed at least 82

Several children ‘seriously unwell’ amid rise in measles cases as alert issued by NHS

This common bacteria could be the culprit behind ‘millions’ of stomach cancer cases

Elon Musk may not be the president, but he still has cards to play against Trump

Mukesh Ambani’s middle class special GIFT, give your old clothes and take branded clothes- Read

Mum hits back at TfL for ‘blaming her’ for losing arm and leg under Tube trains

Brit ‘outraged’ at £3,000 fine for bad review about black mould infested rental home

NHS forces dentist to repay £150,000 ‘because his patients are too healthy’

Here’s how to see the Delta Aquariid meteor shower just around the corner

Teenage girls arrested after woman left with ‘life-changing’ stab wounds

Brooks Nader’s Wimbledon Period Stain Went Viral – Here's Why It Struck A Nerve

Is It Time For A Wealth Tax? Starmer Under Pressure To Ramp Up Charges On The Rich

Trump Goes Off On New Rant Against 'Train Wreck' Elon Musk

Kemi Badenoch Brands Nigel Farage 'A Bulls*****r' In Foul-Mouthed Rant

From The Salt Path To Baby Reindeer – What Does 'True Story' Mean Legally?